Introduction to Dialectics

com s

comay

can figure out of god here

okay seven words left on paper we'll justc that day and you and you

thanks thanks thanks

mm

wo

jesus

right

let's see what we can

what's going on

s

let's see was in the chat did

oh my goda so many youre cant nam you all

what up robert

p up gator blade

jesus man save span the whole fuking chat when i was be

what u bearer rout with subquindy would up swag swag would u ja

on what's up captain delicious what a red ndny and what up temujan

what up

the guy who's the japanese characters i can' read your name have a better name

what up what up dialectical vegan inco egoist what a curse name

what up dan lit

shut ut damn little

they say your volumes too low

my volume is too long

according to gentle ginjee

per

well i don't know why it's it's low i

it shouldn't be b

there's no reason for it to be law

is it really low

guys

is it low

toemmy this well

it doesn't seem like it's slow

this sa some say it's a little

whatbut mind

yours is probably fine

let me see if it's my uh hold on

mis s

they say yours is low relative to mine

jesus

either i should lower its lower it's or you should increasees someway this

how about now is it better now because i just turned off a

it's fine

i can't

lower my mike sensitivity a little

both of you are fine ok

oka

our guys

few quick things we've got to get through before we do this edg you screen

dream

um first of all guys

i sha to talk about that later when it's about the edg you stuff later but i want to get through some some stuff

first

where to begin

sage wants to debate you on lefty pool

why

what do you mean on lefty pool

he wants to come on stream and debate us or he wants me to go type with my fingers and waste my fucking time

type

i don't want to fork

type it's so fucking cut time consuming

and well guys it's up to you actually

if you want me to type there's going to be no streams for weeks

it's either i do streams or i write essays on left popole and i don't want to fok and write essays on left

f

fink it's a waste of time for me

and for everyone else involved

you really want me to go on left you pol and just start typing fucking books for everyone in essays and shit

i promise you it's not going to be

and it's just going to be ugly

trust me it will be ugly

text format

it's so fucking like

my fingers

are so weary of just

why why do people this is the metaphysical battle that's been going on guys

there's a metaphysical battle that's been going on

anglos prefer text

because for them text equals essence

again remember it's protestant is

they want something to be able to reduce they want something eternal timeless

and just static that they can fucking reduce everything to

for them

text equals the true essence they don't actually see truth and meaning and discussion

as something that in unfold

in actual time it actually develops and as something that's actually living in active

they see it as something static in the past

which is why they prefer the text format

over actually using their voice and discussing like human beings

you know

the only reason i i write anything

is either for me as an index of memory

or i have a targeted audience

that's why i haven't released anything to you guys yet because i want to know who my audience is to know

what i should write for the

but anglos have the approach of writing to whom it may concern

to literally any the void or something right

but your audience is always going to be determined because your audience is always going to have

a certain set of ideas in their head a certain range of knowledge in their head

a certain level of familiarity with the words you're going to be using

there's so many variables

you have to have at least some kind of sense of

to affect to write for

so that's why we haven't released any writings or i haven't written anything

for you guys yet

n know

that's why we privilege streaming over type

because

i don't type and i don't make writings to whom it may concern

the only types of writings i make to whom it may concern are for me

as an index of my member

my theory so i can return to it

and

you know i

retrace my steps as far as

where i am theoretically

so

because a word for me triggers a certain association

that same word will trigger an entirely different association for you

words have different

i don't get this later because is actually going to be the

the educational topic of our stream

dialect

believe or not

well he can't debate in person he's just too slow

the thing is guys about why i say come debate me

the thing about that

is that

i actually have no intention

of

being like wasah and destiny and gaslighting in real time

and just

doing it for the purposes of attack

the reason i'm always telling people to come on stream is because when you come on stream

you actually have to treat me like a human being

and you have to give me the assumption

that i am trying to say something meaning

ok

and every time we've had anyone on as long as they've been polite

i've been polite too and i try to establish some kind of common meaning

i try to adjust how i speak

to accommodate others and where they are and what words and associations they're familiar with

i try to help anyone who

who's looking for

i work with

that's what i'd like to do

when it comes to having discussions

i want to work with

so when i'm engaging in debates

in shit

i'm always on the defense

it's up to you to come on stream show your face and try to attack me

i'm never going to be the person who's on the offens

and who's just going to try to

have someone come on and completely gas like

it's it

i always afford everyone including my enemies

the benefit of trying to say something and communicate something meaningful

it doesn't matter if it's my worst enemy on falcking earth

i always afford my enemies the benefit

that they are trying to communicate something meaningful

ok

so

i'm always going to be on the defensive

so if you want to come on stream and attack me

i will defend myself

and i will successfully defend myself

i mean at least that's the most likely out

f as i'm

but you're right i can't pretticy

i

that's why we want people

to speak and use their voice

that's why we prefer that type of medium

because when you type your bluff

typing words text is abstraction

bluff

there's a guy behind the fuck and keyboard

and there's an audience

that typing is addressed

you know it's bluffing to only

only fu

it's just focking bluff

because at the end of the day we're all human beings

and we all have this intention

to communicate some kind of meaning

when we're engaging in communication

ok

when you're typing you're bluffing that you're not actually addressing only human beings you're also speaking to god himself or

it's just fucking bluff

and i don't have fucking time

know

i would rather have a constructive

engagement of s

kind

you know

i

reminds me of the dogs they have a tendency to bark at you and they are

behind a fence and they will make it seem like they're repeated pieces

that's exactly it

that's literally exactly it

literally the biggest form of bluffing ever

yeah i know du

i'm not one of those people

who when i see debate i'm not talking about like a high school debate club where there's formal rules

who won the debate of course

and i don't i don't care about any of that

when i see debate i mean

attack me with the same ferocity

and the same dismissiveness

try doing that when you're face to face with me and you fucking can'

that's my fole fucking point about a debate

my whole point of a debate

isn't where i think it's a game where whoever's like wash and destiny do it

i don't see debate

that way

i want people to come on

and explain their problem with us explain your

if you can't communicate your beef to us

f you can't afford us the assumption of being human beings trying to communicate

meaningful things

you're just fucking bluffing behind your keyboard

that's my fucking point

you know

could you forgive redeemed sage

he wanted it

if he apologized and stop being so fucking annoying

of course i would forgive

see

but he comes on and he's so fucking annoying

and

it's like

it's like you're not even dealing with a human being

he doesn't act fucking human

as we what's that word in chinese

where it's like being human

where they just say like just be human

or uh

just sort and

its litterary means s ubin

s

and sage can't do that

you just can't

be human

can't act

in a human fucking way

you know that's why he mechanically and robotically just spams things

he doesn't want to establish any meaningful bridge of communication

doesn't want to work with us

he just wants to spam fucking phrases and annoy us

that's why we have this problem with

autism boxes

you know

it's because it ultimately comes to this robotic bluffing

jack

yeah i'm not going to get in

the debate moderator says i can't docs or issue death threats to my

year

exactly dark worries

anglo debate is theatric

and real debate is about discovering truth

it's exactly that

i think it's what i have

drilled in my brain the debate is conflict the losers humiliated therefore permanently wrong can't

son and stup

we don't want that approach

but we're never the ones

who who refused to afford other people the

benefit of communicating human meaning

that's the thing

so we want people to come and try to

dismiss us like how they're doing with their fuck

fingers

keyboard

and i want to i want to show you guys how much they're going to fail in doing it

when they actually try to talk to us

one on one

because when they talk to us one on one they're going to have to afford us the benefit

that were human beings

trying to communicate something meaningful and they're going to try to have to work with us to see

what we are trying to say in good faith

that's why

one dislike say yeah i know

but it's supposed to be a way to come to a mutual understanding of both developerspo that's what i prefer to but again there are people hostile to us like vosh

and that will be a con

you know that will be a conft

but infrared

is never going to

to outright dismiss you know infrared is not when we debate people like vosh and all those people

we're not going to be like oh you're any empirical facts it doesn't matter we we are going to hold wash to his commit

and hold him to his

issue

and hold him to the meaning he communicates

we're going to deal with him on those terms

we're not going to say

you know oh according to the facts and of our the meeting according to the tre definition of dictionary you got it wrong

i don't i don't know i don't believe that's a way to engage anyone

even if it's my worst fucking enemy

not a way to engage any

i

dislikes the haves agorithm yeah i don't care about

se nine viewers almost

blass

am

i want to give you guys an example of this i don't know if i was going to share this

but for example we'll get comments like this

ok

and this is sage by the

this is say

not danll led bed that's a cool guy

shining path is safe

and i want to show you

why we don't want to engage in tex debate

and we're not going to engage with people in text form

unless we're defending something we put out tex

then well i'll probably go and defend it

people want to challenge

text

and i'll wipe the foot

or

just like how

know i'm life

but

this is why

and it's just this is the crux

so then bill comes in good faith

is he aware of you n know he's not aware of us but i'm just saying like that's an example of someone who's clearly hostile

almost a complete

damn this country of sixty people in a classroom yet

voss spends his

he probably had knows about us but they're probably looking at us and just seeing

how far is this going to go

and they're going to eventually see we're going to get really big

we are going to get we already are getting really big at an extremely rap

pigs

one hob

no't

so been

but anyway daniel this is a fine question

he says not sure what this video was in

can you explain what you mean by post imperialism and your analysis of why you think we live in post

perio was

imperialsm still works with the importan export of finance capital

the tmost competition is for the control he's explaining the

lennon's imperialism

acord tohim

times have changed for sure

the new it's not the same as wmenro his book but the empires present the empires a sending act

to the precepts laid out in the high states of capitalism

i want to remind you guys some

remind you guys of some

we made a pool

long time ago

here

and we made this poll for you guys

and we linked it

to you guys

and so everyone

you know we tried to get everyone

to be able to see this pool

twenty eight people voted

for it

and everyone wanted the next educational stream to be into the dialectics

so an intro to imperialism stream

is going to come after this

it's not going to be this stream

that's the reason

i don't want to delve more into this issue of imperialism

because

you guys aren't familiar with our position

it's a complicated position and i want to be able to

to communicated in the best way in the most

formative way in

most clear way possible

i also don't want to type sentences

that i know people in bad faith are going to take and try to reduce the whole of our extremely complicated

addition to

because again

that's the anglo approach

trying to look for the substantial essence of

that is somehow static and inscribed in time

before the fact

that's not a search for communicating human meaning that's a stt's a necrophilia searching for dead things and dead objects

i

to worship

we need to make

no we don't need to go

i

that's that's the reason that's the reason and another another reason to

another reason to besides the fact that i don't want to

engage in all this kind of

what's up break

engage in all this kind of typing in my fucking comments and writing books and my comments trust me i've been down this path

for ok trust me i have

i don't want to fulcking you

i don't want to fok and argue

on the fucking internet

with

it's such a waste of time it's such a fucking waste of time and it's always just going to end

with the opponent

giving up

because if they do not have more energy

then me

trust me they don't

okay

but anyway

here's what i told him i said i disagree

but we will delve further into the topic in the future

and that's the honest to god true

right

honest got true

fuck the drama this isn't drama i'm just going to

i'm just going to use this as an example and we're also going to look at the new read it that needs made

and check out that ready

i

he said but when

and indvidual be great you have at least one so this is a good faith guy asking for a one minute explanation

okay

exactly dialectically was the only dead thing is an abstraction

and that's what anglo seem to worsh

and that's why it's necrophilia

and individu be great you have at least one minute explanation for now

ok

that's a good that's a good a's eas asking a question in good faith

i

i said here's my one minute explanation

there's aspects of nineteenth century capitalism that persisted when lennon wrote imperialism

they just became super

there are aspects of imperialism that persist up to the present day

it's just that they became superf

it's not actually what in the main defines the era post breton wouldd

brennon woods by the ways the monetary arrangement

that emerged after world war two between the united states

and

the rest of the non communist world

more or less

that's ultimately would strick

we are in a not we're not just in op pose ok so i just said all this stuff

and i also gave him a good intro

to the american uni polar era which is the very young azeo foxs book

the global minotar

it's not a perfect book it's not a great book

but it contains a lot of good facts

and information

ok so that's why i recommended this

we are so

he said nice and then he said you know he disagreed more

and he he and then i said

for us polarity has a special conceptual relevance that isn't just political

it's also economic

ok that's what we said

so going back to this

what was it that i was trying to communicate

what i was trying to communicate here

is that if i consider our era to be post imperialism

it isn't because it liquidates or invalids

invalidates lenin's imperialism

it's because i think lenin's imperialism

ok

has been subsumed

you want

by a greater

type of the

a greater type of process of

pack

that's all i meant

this is the only thing i meant to communicate we don't reject lenin's imperialism

we just think

similar

to

nineteenth century capitalism it has become absorbed

part of a greater

and

i don't want to say system but a

a greater historical

development

cross

ok let's just call it that

that's the only thing i wanted to communicate i didn't make any argument

i didn't make some partisan position and i'm going to defend with a debate

i don' not make any state empirically controversial statement

i just communicated that we don't reject lenon's imperialism

that's all i meant to communicate

so here comes sage

and sage was so humiliated by last dream

and he made a fake account called shining path

and he thought this was going to be his opportunity to expose infrared

and he wants us to

give him a string of words

that he can completely

he can completely debunk

right by taking it in bad faith taking it out of context

taking it in isolation

so he can run back to lefty pool and say he beat hot

and it's so fucking pathetic

at this point

at this point

sages become our goll

you know

it's really sad

he's really become our god

you know this guy

thisy much what he's become

in the beginning he k approached the hobbits

and he approached gandolf and all those i don't know w those people were

and at first he acted like he was their friend and he was nice

he said

what did he say

come check out my thread

check out mine stad

about

the global goolad

please come check it out and i went and checked out his thread

and it turned out to be fucking stupid and i didn't like his threat but i tried to be polite about

then he went fucking crazy and he became sneagle

the deceiver and the annoying

you know this is what i think of when i think of say

it's this

it's literally this f were strong proces you bg

may appreciate

how the fungs you figure out it was safe

six all of ten impression

because i figured out it was saved

because

there's no one this but her who's against

and

he's yeat he's clear the type of guy who would do

you know

but

this is what he's become to us and i actually feel bad for him

that's why i was engaging him in the chat because i don't want to be this sadistic guy

who has this pet

smeagle with this pet reek

and i don't want

and i want people to be dignified human beings all

i don't want infrared

to have these despicable creatures

as our servants and our jesters

play

i want everybody to be able to redeem their self selfs

so that's why i was being polite

you know

yeah

that's why i was bulling polite if i was an abusive type of guy

maybe i would take

but honestly going back

about it

you know i just don't want

i don't want this type of

humiliated creature

and maybe he has a b d s m fets like neat pointed out

he might have a humiliation fetish

and i kind of feel dirty

and i kind of feel

not right

like

feeding into this guy who gets off

on i'm being like

you know

so

the angle of view history is a status set of dead facts of that events

yeah

i

the general consensus is he's a fed

i've had an encounter believe it or not in you tube comment

about half a decade ago more than half a decade ago

and there was a guy who did act like say

his argumentation shit

but here's the scary thing guys

is that this valking guy

told me the exact amount of money i had in my bank account

with no other information to go of

they had no information about

they didn't have my e mail they didn't have my name they had zero information about me

and they guessed

they didn't guess they

they commented

they said the exact amount of money i had in my bank account

time which is like

two hundred thirty four dollars in

de s

more

isn't that fucking scary

and i think that was a fed honest

i really do what do you guys

i

i tried to as people in our group

who that could have possibly been

i know yet it is his comments i shared it on twitter

i

maybe he has a bd s m fetish

no i didn't say like me di i say like me i didn't mean

i

he said

this is what his argument was

talk so much that you say so little idiot

right off the bat if you're going to be rude to me i'm not going to fuck and help you

i am under no obligation to help you if you're going to fucking be rude

functionality iperalism was not dependent on whether french or germans or british prevailed

which is a funny thing to

to say because i didn't say anything about that

it's the basis in the economical not the geopolitical

but i already said that for us polarity

has economic relevance it has special conceptual relevance

sage came in here

and wanted to immediately

debated

but just going off my youtube account isn't that crazy that they knew my exact bank account shit

financial capital extraction from the periphery is not superfluous this is

some hear i means world system theory take

it's the core of the economic relationship between the us westlak and the perip

ok so he just made an assertion

and i just said keep barking dumb fuck

keep barking i'm not going to address your views

if you're going to be rude

and you didn't say anything of any significance

you if you were't you would expand what the fuck you were talking about

why would i do that when you're going to be rude to me who are you

and where did you come

but no you coed trigger to that

called you out of being an idiot because you're a bad faith actor being fucking group to me i'm not going to help you

try to clarify and

and i said you didn't make an argument he said response go to make one

he said ok let's start again

he just repeated the same thing he said

this is autism by the way this is autism what have tri

come on can we please forget and say we know it

i this is going to be the last

thing about say

and is because

this is going to go out

to be a general

w'm go to i'm going to take the red it up

and then we'll

i want its i want to take a tweet and show you gus a tweet

there's a few things i want to

worry

yeah

i

you didn't tell ok then he said

you didn't tell me about

what made post breton woods capitalism diff

but we never we never

gave you any indication

that we intended on telling you that we said we're going to have a stream

and we'll clarify it more and net stream

when did you get this idea that you're entitled to an explanation

you just made that statement and then pointed out to the subsequent

i didn't make a statement i clarified that we

don't

rebuke

lenin's imperialism we just think

there's something else going on we in a laboratey we didn't explain upon

nor did we have any obligation

i don't know where you're getting this idea that we had an obligation to do that

we did it

but he wanted me to do

was write a paragraph

condensing really complicated views that need extensive elaboration

in order to get a gotcha

and reduce us to some ridiculous

substance it's again the classic anglo position

they want something static

finite

sorry definite

eternal

to

pin as the essence

the true essence

a string of words to reduce everything

ok

sorry

that's not how human communication

were expression of meaning

works

ok

you have to begin first

with a good faith assumption on meaning of meaning on our part

i

of trying to say something

i were going to talk about it later in the in the dialogue

yeah exactly and i'm glad you guys can all see this

right

i'm glad you guys can all see this

me giving yeah and i explain this and then this is where the comedy begins

and this is what i want to show

i

why should i care about whether you yeah exactly

this is read this comment guy

this is really

this is fugging hilarious dude he said

running back live on camera

to your chat

but isn't it more balsy to be live on camera

than to type in the fucking common section like a bitch

whenever you backed into a corner how is we how we backed into a corner

if someone in the chat

sees it that i don't see it

how how we backed into a corner

your pre you're probably copy pasting from archived comments on our communism one to one

you know it's interesting a lot of people accuse us

of basically

saying things without elaborating on them or just

not giving the proper definition

this is the opposite of what we do isn't it

we don't say things in ways people are already familiar

and purposefully too

we don't want to

virtue signal

communist or marxist talking points

that you find on the internet because we think those are really misleading

so we're not doing that

and people regularly give a shit over that fact

which is why you have nothing left to say to me

ok do

it's like you could tell it sage because nobody else gets this close to me like brochs take a few steps back

honest

i don't like you like

understand just please

i can smell you

take it it's like he's trying to grab my dick or some

u

use

take a few steps back you are way too close

you are way too close

way too close

ok i accept your concession

here we go with the b d s

a

the bd s

fetishism

you should not let your

you know i don't know what he's doing

rea guess gs we go on the twitter and read it

walking away

all that time spent doing sports and working out who would have thought

that didn't mean shit in the marketplace of idea

he's getting all of this shit

people like me who debunk you

which

ok

he demonk does i guess your ability to make a basket from a three point line

when did i say i played basketball

as much as your anorexic ex girlfriend

who's king now chn

i mean met because i'm the streamer

and you're writing my dick dud

don't forget where you are right now you're in the comon section of my video

so it sounds like i'm still king i don't know what you guys

my intellect to superior you belong the leeches and parasites of the labor move

what do i have to do with the labor movement

that he's talking

like what do i have to do with

and i just said come on stream if you want to challenge it

you have to put skin in the game because we're putting skin in the game

you're the one who came to us we didn't come to you

you know

ah

yes

and then there's one another thing i wanted to show you guys really quick

is

this reminded me

why don't you read this guy's is this is the most pathetic fucking thing you ever read

i hope everyone has fun talking about forced the vote for yet another day

i will be in negotiations for a collective bargaining agreement all day

doing something actually tangible for work

people

best of luck to the discorse

shut the fock up

who

whyse what the funct does that have to do with force the vote

this is such disgusting

opportunism

oh while you're talking about while you're talking about

the struggle for true executive dictatorship in supremacy and actual political power

and you're talking about that struggle

i will be sweating and being suffering and being in pain

doing tangible things

youve got this cocktail of seventeenth century anglo metaphysics

and

vulgar protestant calvinistic

self flagellation i know that's a catholic thing but

worship of suffering

i don't respect this i don't know this is been the talking point of the democrats for many years now

is basically

oh whiy you're working on this whole bernie thing

meanwhile hillary clinton

and obama we're actually helping people in the real world

trying to get real health care instead of

bernie sanders pine the sky medicare for all

oh while you

we're talking about abstractions

i went and voted for biden

tangibly helping kids and kids it's like shut the fuck up dude

this is why americans need this type of spiritual

existential

phills out ediological whatever they need some type of revolution

to free themselves

from this

posturing

because all this is all left is fucking do is they advertise pain and self

listen

i'm not going to shit on people who do charity

because you actually are helping people and that's fine

but the minute you're doing charity of some kind and yes what she is doing does amount only to charity

you're tangibly helping people on an individual level that's the de

you want an angle

that's vulcan haer

ok

this is charity

and i'm not going to respect you doing this in fact i'm going to spit on you

metaphorically speak

when you go on twitter and start bragging about it

in trying to contrast this

to things like force the vote

when you use this as an excuse to contrast it

bigger issues

i'm going to shit on you i'm not going to respect

they you're

you're suffering to tangibly help you

it doesn't command my fulk

that

because you're using it for attention

and you're using it

to virtue signal

then it completely look it completely annihilates everything you're trying to say

and do

i have no respect for it

whatsoever

and i'm so sick of americans being conned by this

stupid fucking bluffing in blackmail

i will be in a shut the fuck up who gives the shit

go fucking do the

no difference from

no biden and saying

i can get things done you know it's always a blackmile it's being a blackmile for decades and still the same blackmile

this is why anglo materialism

and

fighting it

has such concrete relevance even on a political level

because the cult of so called tangibility

can only persist

subsist

within a pre established range of possibilities

when you're trying to challenge the range of possibiliti

you're inevitably not going to be doing the tangible things

that are currently considered possible

that's why

a dialectics for example has concrete relevance

helping americans

i was going to trigger a lot of people progressive forces as ambiguous as that sounds

fight for things like jimmy dor

it's going to help them

clarify

and fight against this retarded fucking

anglo protestant i don't know what to call it

mentality that has literally retarded the left

and is the quintessential expression of opportunism

among the left

it's a form of emotional manipulation i know do it it is

it is

it's exactly

folk

form of a motion

i mean collective bargaining is important

ok it may be important but in what context

because

you know

here it's not important

it just isn't

your virtue signaling about it like you said

it's virtue sing yeah i don't care if people want to collective bargain that's fine

that's fine

you know this is one of the last things i want to say about this whole union thing

right we're coming under fire for supposedly being against unions in the union movement

i

which is really dishonest

because we didn't do that

and i don't know maybe unions are some new thing that are

you know the future of everything

but from my experience for people my age

their heads and their hearts are not there

their minds and hearts are not it's mostly these kind of hipster people

you know

if you know what i'm talking about you know what i'm talking

but

i'd very skeptical i'm very sceeptical

because why are google engineers now unionized

why is folking everyone unionized

hm

even all the fucking petty booge what type p m c

type of elements are unionizing

i'm very sceeptical

if you want my two cents but i could be wrong i'm open to being wrong

i'm open to being wrong

but

i feel like it's another it's a type of attention blackmail

because

they want to capture people's attention

and they're not doing it as successfully as to cast you six notine

something you know what i mean

and this is a demographic has to not go soon

oh you got to go soon

but um before i go i'm just going to say

tomorrow we're going to have a special screen with a special guest

uh it's gon to be

six p m e s t

um

and i'm going to be

the main guy hosting so i'm not just going to be chill you around so if you get many of you could really get tired of hazzi should show up for tomorrow but

i'm just nobody will gets ever gets hired off us

all i see you guys

guys yet tomorrow six pm as there is going to be leading that

that show

and it's good we're going to be interviewing

can't pronounce his name

sorry for that but

he's a prominent guy on twitter

and it's going to be a really sick

so i recommend all of you guys

tomorrow it

i

yeah

yeah that's the guy who's come

and ezra set the whole thing up so i don't

there's i'm kind of in the dark about a lot of things

i

yeah the stream will be in english the stream will be in english

and it's going to be our sixth official episode of the infrared show

how because we have different episodes where we ent

and but this one's going to be the first one that's live

i

it's going to be the first one that's live

okay i think we're going to check the rebdit now

and then i'm going to go right into

the dialogue introduction to dialogue

so let's check out this new ready

on

right off the bat

see in some

seeing some stuff

us does

direct strike

my precious

up

yeah i mean

i don't know what to fuck and say you know it just

yeah

all right nice

oh my god u is what is my cultu of personality read it

i

wow what is that

what is this flower that don't get this

nice pick though

i'm going to oup for

will infrared be answering questions

yes

what the

fuck is going on

wo wait a minute

it's the fucking mossad agent guys we need another character

bring out the means we need this is were going to have more recurring character

for context

there was a mossad agent one suspecting is one

who is in a lefty pool thread who used this copy posture from his mossage brochure

two cent

israeli cyber army

shares on the internet

and this guy seems like he's going to be a

regular character

because he made an account

with only one post called has is anti semitic

i

my anti semitic

feel like i'm more semitic than you right

israel is an indigenous state

it's not a crime for indigenous people to declare

and it's the same one

from the brochure of the

id f cyber army that they share on the fucking internet

and he thinks has this is this is almost like sage level

the it's like the i is the idea

have a bunch of sages in it who are begging for hazes attention

get off my cock

i don't care

but

i don't give a shit about his

i

no

i

does israel have the right to

posswill

no

no state

has the right

to exist

you understand

i

so i don't

i don't think isral

just don't

just don't

sorry i don't

um

like i you want to right to exist

how can you know state was formed by saying i have a right to exist like

you know

but

yeah i don't reck i don't i oficially do not recognize as

how about

like i'm i don't know if i speak for everyone infrared

but for me at least there's no israeli embassy we don't recognize israel

and we have no diplomatic relations

this

you know fock fock is real i what

so

i don't

i

i know did we have a whole cast of villains

but

to

we have a whole fuck in

cast of villain

it's fucking crazy s

yeah i know

ignore nonsense ignore massade

seems like this is a regular character we're going to have

be point doctors first question

where's your pass

yeah

modern state yet

i think israel's kind of cringed you

i've never seen like an organic expression of anything israal

israel seems like the most fake state ever

and they try so hard via p r departments to make it seem like they're a thing

oh yeah israel's a thing no israel's not really a thing i think it's completely synthetic artificial

try hard state

it's trying to be a legitimate state

keeps failing

that's my impression it seems like they just try hard they're like reaching

you know like they're trying so hard to be a thing

what that mean girls quote

it's not a thing

ok

like stop trying to make

it

a thing

it's not a fucking thing

o

like

yeah ok i don't want to get

this will get us bandage sh

know this why we can't stream on twitch

because i think you get banned

twitch

talk should about

yes i has

what do you mean we're already living in socialism yet

has you said you areunfamiliar with the communist party peru i'm kind of familiar with them

i'm kind of familiar with them but thanks for the book i'll probably check it out sometime

i

maybe

but i am somewhat familiar with

i'm just

someone came in the chat and asked us a very specific question

have you seen every mares israel yeah i did it i saw that it's crazy

crazy

israel has no history

criminal record

it's my impression too i don't i don't see israel as a legitimate nation

doesn't seem like a real state

seems like completely synthetic artificial

anglo america

project

i see a anddre amin also bo

named

it's called

i

i don't know

check out the read it and just click the read it

check out the ready

they got the redy

sohow picture those who don't

who don't get whit house cause a status quo

source oil i forgot let mean

yes the answer this is yes

does anybody have a list of all the big corporations with marxist uses

funny

yeah dude no one cares no one really gives a shit

i mean like no one cares

about

it's socialism isn't shocking it's like the default now you know

i think you're right we should obomas private corporation

look how easily she responds to that

that's yeah it's a good example to

what a bucking liar dude

just because i said we're going to educational stream does mean it's the next stream

so

we're here now

like in terms

do you love black people and reparations

for your

racism

what a strange question

on

what a weird question

i don't know what

what you're asking

i

what is this

what the fug is this

look at this

say just something

but this is a legendary folk

picture do it i save this picture

this is a legendary picture

i don't know who made this who made this fucking pig

step up and take credit

for making this pit

is a sick picture

i love this

whoever made this

pole is still here

no no no don't don't don't

we're not going to ban

unless they

do bannable shit

so i think someone

is sharing us around

like right wing image boards

our leftist is doing

by the way it's a co hundred percent leftist

and it's funny

because they always accuse us of being nosballs and shit

but when push comes to shove

at the end of the day

you know

at the end of the day

like

yeah they just i guess they they they stoop to that level because that's how much that they're left

thirt

like who's the true leftist here right

they're going on pool and they're going all over these image boards and sharing our stream

but what they don't understand

did they do that just now youre arasian supremacist because i saw they did that last stream

they did it last stream

and

i don't know why

people do it

because

i'm not

scared like i'm not scared of people from those images

's not

yeah i know did i saw that last stream but did they do it again

let them do it again dude we need attention we need exposure

i

and who knows maybe a lot of the will find us interesting

you know

i don't care

it's not like

i don't know why they think this is ourki achilles yl giving us free attention

even if we get brigaded with

dislikes

and negative comments

that's still attention dude

i

prices

good press right how they say it

but what a fucking loser left is to

i hate left this

more than those poll people because at least poll people are honest about who they are in shit

but meanwhile leftist

act like there i'm the real leftist antifa

and then you're a fascist ties you're a fascist

but then they go on pol and share us because the're that buthard and that much little bitches

and they're trying to run to b p please attack he go ahed attack her

dude but paul hates you

more than i do

they hate you more than i do dude

you are the fucking left that cancels them

and deep platforms people

d platform alex jones on if you are the very left

that they hate

i have nothing to do with you

meanwhile

i didn't i don't care about cancell culture in deep laft

six

you're the left they hate dude stop trying to run to poll

have them attacked to me

when they hate you more than they hate me probably

right

yeah i know

free advertising exactly

like they think they can stop us or hurt us somehow

you can

you really can't do there's nothing you can do

there's nothing you can do about infrared dude we're unstoppable we're going to keep growing

we're going to take down fosh

we're going to change the whole game

cannot be stopped

can share us wherever you want

go ahead shares

what do you mean strikes hard

direct tax

isn't it this thlough isn't this type of smeagle creature we're dealing with

who's doing this type of shit

le's wll actually allows paul to debate us

yeah i mean i'm not scared of debate i'll debate anyway

yet

mm

what you mean strikes our direct action

direct action

that

previous votes what' this

as looket forrom you

it saves disgrace

wow dude even on left boll they voted he was disgraced this is cool

even on lefty poole they disgraced him just like i said he's disgraced forever bears suff

six hours stream time

this time hopefully not

what

whatc is this

haz his love

late

turn to monkey

for me

w is this like my culture personality threat

anglohotism bogs

one

this video was'dre

all right i think that's it i think that's all on the read it let's refresh one more time

or someone

so much here thats nice

twenty seven members while we're growing

we're growing

f a third down pool

it's already on page eight and going to get provee soon three

applies and nobody cares yeah i doubt anyone gives a fuck

but you see how isn't it direct action

cancelling poll based the redirecting poll to other leftists

great

well that's what they do dude that's what they do

but serusly how isn't a direct action because this like watch our previous dream d

there's a guy who kept scamming us about it it's

i've explained i'm not going to explain it again how about that i'm not going to explain

it's just going to take too long to get explain again someone in the chat explain to the

i just can't i don't have energy explaining

how ha sees himself

this is the most low effort post but at least you're

keeping it going

all right that's that's enough for that

and some that ok guys

i'm going to

here's what we're goninga do

think you need to let me in

no i don't

a there is someone who shared us on poll

that i am seen in my discourse

yeah dud one guy liked us

yeah this isn't that hostile dude lefty polls way worse to us lefty pulls way worse to us than pull

isn't that sad

lefty pol hates us way more

left us hate us way more

on

okay i'm goinga

open up m s paint

because that's how this is going to work for this intro to dialectics

we're going to go back to emis paine

and

where is the window capch

oh it's right

right here and then

okay

i'm going to be right back

and

will

put this aside for now

because

we don't need this to distract

and i'm going to be right

back

ok i'm going to right back

im goming to just blow my nose a beit or two seconds

all right come back

don't worry guys i'm still here

i'm still here

on

yeah it seems like people on pull

do like us better

give us a rundown on what you are all about i don't understand how you can idolize lenin marx and trotsky unless you are jewish

well we're not trotsky is

but

i don't i i that doesn't brian that doesn't make sense because

despite the fact that in europe

there they were very jews were very prominent

for obvious reasons

i

in marxism and also in all everything revolutionary and pretty much

interesting that was going on in europe from philosophy to such

freud psychoanalysis

phenomenology neo conti all this interesting stuff was going on in europe

jews were involved right

because there

you know

but

for most marxist leninists

you know you can't read that's why you don't really see anybody making anti semitic conspiracies about

vietnam and china

cuba

flucking

the majority of countries

like and nobody makes you know nothing nobody makes anti semitic claims about like bresnev soviet

it's only in likek the twenties before

world war two

that people are obsessed with this whole like anti semitic

right

n i know he's from paul it's ok

ok

why post on lit

i didn't

bob horkin

leftists don't like me

left to sve me they accuse me of being a nosball

and they don't like us

because

we're not politically correct pretty much

so they're trying to go run to you guys on fortune

to come get us

like basically

it's like b pretty much like these

they're pretty much like hillary clinton and t for left

you know what i'm saying

and they have a problem with infrared because infrared is coming from a

so yeah

that's that's pretty much was going on we did not

i i didn't go on for i' never been on for tun and before i never shared nothing on there

we got leftist haters going onftune

to trk because they want to cancel us right because they're accusing us of being anti semitic

they're accusing us of being too wok

they're accusing us of being

the nosbels their kingos been all sorts of things which were not

we're not

but

that's what's going on base

that's why we've been shared all over fortchen we're being shared on pol

be in sured on lift

other leftists are very but heard about us in the first thing the decided to do

guan pool

because they want to see us

gone

because they can't cancel us

so now they're turning to poll to get the job done

but

infrared jus is not going anywhere you know

but h you know

i can understand

that you're coming in here thinking were the aggressors were the ones going out around

sharing ourselves around

we're not doing a duty

we're not

you know

but feel free to stick around no

i guess all preped

oh

what do they say all attention is good attention right

all p r is good p r

someone wants to debate you on pool

well they can d m me on twitter

twit it dot constant shoan for red

and i'll let them on the show and they can come

debate

but we kind of want to get into this dialect

as long as there are you know polite

sir

not going to give me band

alexander i don't know why you just

marrige

twe minutes

what is the marxist end game though

we don't think in terms of end games

we just want to be delivered

to the development of contradictions as they actually unfold in reality itself

so

there is no real end goal it's just it's almost like acceleration ism right

it's about unleashing the forces of production

and it's about the perseverance of humanity after modern

my rundown

so

it's about overcoming anglo saxon modernity that's what i think marxism is about

overcoming and moving beyond anglo saxon lagernity

i

this stream might be his first copy stright no we've had copyright

streams will

work

communist murder my countryman comis to the enemies of an which countryman robal country from

they're banned from twitters make a new twitter

tkn a twitter

as a whole

chill do that i live in america so

sho with

but chill with that kind of shit

i'm saying

to with that's a we got that mossad guy that id f army guy

coming and attacking us

so i'm already in the spotlight by somebody you know

so let's chill with that stuff

for some reason i'm already in the spotlight weve got the fuck in two cent i d f army

writing essays and brochures for us

so

poland

dude

wasn't poland based under communism

but then they became

open to american globalism liberalism

mike

yeah there was there was world war two and shit

but pretty much after the smoke cleared

i'm pretty sure polish people

kind of had it better off

maybe i'm wrong

communism can be beat capitalism can be beaten

bob you must not know that we already live in so

capitalism is already a fake

capitalism is a complete myth du

look what happened games stop there is no capitalism

it's already fucking defeated

you know

it's already gone

trust me the federal reserve

already plans our economy

game

we already live in social

even libertarians know that we don't live in

real capitalism

as we're back i don't is he back

who's back

don't se anyone

i've seen on

a fortune gang

yeah guys reminder i'm not the one who shared

this stream to fortune you know

wasn't me

you are wrong

i don't think i am dude i think it depends on wh talked

right i think in poland people were working in like steel factories had dignified lives and shits

now they have to be

er drivers and shit probably right

what are you what are your goals in plain ingglish please i'm not up to date in your lingo

i

to bring down the american establishment

and usher and help

accelerate the new era of multipolarity

etceter etcea

and

surpassing of liberalism

and anglo saxon modornity

pridate communism no breadlines no one v be no show trials

for who though

robert

first of all n k v d

that happened immediately after world war two

but then

the smoke cleared a little bit

and then people you know kind of got on

for the first time people were educated

for the first time people had access to

basic

human

necessities and ship

sit

it depends on who you were

uhuhhuh

calling

the federal reserve does socialism is an insult

guys stop being fucking trigger i'm talking to people from pol

guys are such bad you guys cock blocking

me

and you have like bad optics i don't wt to fucking doing

ok

woman rights in communist poland yet

i found this from fortune you make sense so far go ahead is with thoughts

thank you bro s i you from fortchan are so much more polite

so much more even when they're

saying

h things i disagree with

the people from lefty poole hate me so much more dude

lefty pool nerds see so much when they watch the stream

and even people from porchs

fortune treatment with respect

even though believe it or not dde i'm not the one who shared it there

it was a fucking but her guy from lefty pool

who thinks they were going to bring us down

someone go tell that guy from leftypole his plan failed

we had public sing povate communism

i know but

still do

is is the american liberalism really better than communism i'm not sure

start the tielectics lecture already

all right fine

i'm

ok when to started

now we're in s the dialectics thing

not

okay

first

things first

first things first

yeh it's calm down and start shitting on fast yeah

well guys in the chat you take over from me

if more people come and they're asking why did you shareus and shit

just tell them the story tell them a butt herd left people guy shared us

and that's why we've been we were sharped

what the fulk is multipolarity anglo saxon modernism that sounds like fuck whitey to me

it's not fuck white you do

well who's whity you know

there's also continental europe

france and germany

and there's eastern europe and there's russia

and you know

sort of like

i don't know

don't tell you

ok

that's not this

let's start this

is going tough

want to start it now

let me ok what i wanted to say in the beginning of stream

let me preface this by saying

god i came in to shit all over you but although you obviously don't know much about posh history

your common section is just

but although you don't know much

for history no problese i'm sure topic to people

but your common section is just retarded

i will just be patient you know just be patient

try to talk yeah yeah dude i

we

you know they i have to i want i promiseed i'll do this educational stream

about dialectics

that's why i'm kind of in a rushes get right into this

you know what otherwise

wow we're going to itighty views today it's focking crazy all time im

whoever shever was trying to strike us by sharing us around

for chan and shit

literally is going to like

they're going to break our all time high end ews

terms of how many people are watching

so that's crazy that but her guy from lefty pool

do

what a failure

ok sorry i'm going right into this

prefacing this

prefacing this

i did not have time to really prepare for this stream besides thinking about a few things

i

besides thinking about a few things about what i wanted to say

but the reason for that is that right now i'm in law school

so there's that

i don't have a lot of free time

the other thing though

is that i don't want you guys to overthink this

i want this to be a chill stream i don't want you guys and most the time when you talk about education

people are going to be intimidated

peop were going to be like

would this is the authority do it's not like that i'm not going to speak from an authoritative place

where i'm going to say

you have to believe i'm not going to give you definitions and axioms and

all the empirical statistics and i have focken should like lost

i'm going to work with you the chad

and i want you guys to bear with me and i want you guys to be brutally honest about whether any of this makes sense

to you

because that's my goal is to make it make sense

and

what we're going to do here

is yeah fucking crazy d we

we're hitting eighty you are just fucking and saying

what we want to do here is basically

ok brian i'm going to answer this last question and then i got to get into this educational stream that i that was planned before ok

what is multipolarity

ok

multipularity

multipolarity means

that america

america is no longer

boss this is like dodgin said

you are not boss

so you've got china rising you've got russia rising you got brazil rising

you've got all sorts of cut different countries

that are becoming pollir polar centers in the world it's no longer just america in charge

ok

how is anglo saxon not md moderism not fuck whitey

you just said it wasn't

what depends on what you mean by white

ok if you mean if you mean anglo saxon

the supremacy

then i guess fuck whitey right

but i'm pretty sure most

europeans

there's there's more to europe than just

anglo saxon

modernity and i think the german conservative revolution thinkers of the one nine hundred twenty s and thirties

would kind of agree with what i'm saying

about that woll

you know

and yet

so

that that's that

you know i don't want to

we actually are going to continue this angle theme in the dialectics thing so maybe stay tune

and

yeah

yeah it's 's a go t's g right into this ok

the first thing i wanted to do

was

preface this by saying

i want to

put a disclaimer

disclaim right

because this is something i noticed with our last educational stream and it' is something i noticed with all of the attempts we make to introduce new concepts and new ideas to you guys

re these present old concepts in new ways

i'm going to add a disclaimer

disclaimer

right

and what are we going to say

we're going to say

disclaim

the following stream

is going to

going to present

dialectics in a way

that you will not be immediately

familiar with that means we are not

not going to virtue

signal any of the phrases talking points

were things

you've heard about what dialectics is in the past

we're going to start from scratch based on simple common sense

and hopefully relate

what we arrive at to some of the things

your

you are familiar with

we want to present

something old

in a new

any

brand new way

putting it in new words in order to clarify many confusions and dogmas that now prevail

regarded

concept

this is our disclaimer

yeah this is our disclaimer

okay

so i want to give you guys this

basically

you're not going to be familiar with

how this is something i notice

many people are looking for us

to hit

tick boxes

of talking points they've heard before

because they don't actually want to learn anything new

they want to test us and see if we're familiar with the things they're familiar

well you're just going to have to take my word at the fact that i am

fully familiar with all the shit

that you're familiar with

when it comes to dialect

i just think

they're very vague and confusing and leading to a lot of errors and opportunism

so i want to present it in a new way

o from scratch

completely bypassing all of that

if you can do the work of thinking you'll see how it's all related

you'll see

how this is related to what lennin said and what mark said and what angles directly said

but i'm not going to repeat you phrases and sentences

you know mantras and all sorts of

textualistic talking

point

just to kind of confirm and

scratch that itch you might have for me to just

speak from this legitimate

you know official and orthodox perspective

and the and the bible said it so you know it's not where i'm in forred is coming from whatsoever

you're just going to have to get over that

i'm also going to make another disclaimer

another disclaimer

how you

how

you

what you take away from this stream is going to be entirely

up to you

no matter what we say or how we say it

to

people

are

are going to try and say it is completely

meaningless bullshit that makes no sense whatsoever

and

is all

t midly the equival

but went to saying

notough

thingk at all

i can't help

i can't

control this i can't do anything

anything to stop

people from making

from making

those claims

so it is ultimately up to you the viewer to decide whether

a meaning is being communicated here or not

i am not going to

i'm not going to

try and convince you that i'm

a human being

trying

to communicate something meaningful for a reason

you either accept this assumption or don't

your choice

okay

thess and the thess

synthesis dude

set up

thatbsoally the opposite of what we're going to fo

okay

yeah

alright

all right

so

now we're going to have the intro to dialect

speak

now

believe it or not

i was going to make a video

in the beginning

addressing this issue of language

what it was of agan cast there seems to be a problem when it comes to language there seems to be a problem

when it comes to the use of language

a

disc

discored

ok

jesus fucking cries

guy will leave me the fuck alon

i sorry

dialectics

ok

for discikes from the massad

agent yet

okay

i was going to make a ten minute video

but i decided not to

and i was going to make this about this issue of language

whenever i seem for example the tweet

the tweet i made about

i don't want to bring it up i want to like rehash all this shit

but i basically said something about the difference between

these empiricism kind of things in a dialectic approach

and i said most of the time

when people on the internet for example or in on you tube and all that shit

when they're asking for empirical evidence

the reason isn't because they're curious about

sensory sensory phenomena they're unfamiliar with

but they want some type of idle guarantee of truth

what is an idle guarantee of truth

what did i mean by

well over on left the pool a very smart guy decided to just say that i was speaking nonsense

why

because the phrase idle guarantee of truth

was a new combination of words he wasn't familiar with

and according to him

the only type of words or phrases you can say are virtue signaling talking points someone else already said

but i find this approach to what a concept is

radically unfamiliar

radically alien

forn

to me

i have an active understanding of languag

the main thing the main essence is trying to convey a meaning the meaning is what is essential

to me

the form in which the meaning

is instantiated comes second

the meaning is primary

so using strings of words in ways you're unfamiliar with

in order to convey the deeper meaning to me is more important

theen using straings of words in ways you're already familiar with

in order to virtue signal about

conveyances of meaning

you're familiar with in the past

ca

oh you demank that things i appreciate

appreciate your soldiering doing all the work

doing this kind of work out here

but anyway

i was going to make it about language because it kind of

had me start thinking returning to some things i've thought about many years ago but haven't returned to

and which is be that the relationship the english language has

to the conveyance of meaning

is i think very unique

and very bizarre compared to every other language that i've ever encountered in the world especially as someone who is moderately

i

an airbig speed

not completely hundred percent fluently

i have a guest

lay

i was born

i grew up

um

to me

the english language

unlike other languages

does not rest

upon

well any type of vernacular english is going to be a different story

black vernacular english is similar to the rest of the languages of the world

southern united states vernacular english

similar to the rest of the world

but when it comes to east coast or west coast

formal and official english

the one that's relevant for intellectual discourse and academic discourse

and all that kind of stuff

english seems unique

in each attempt

to pret preemptitively premise

the meaning it attempts to convey

in the very form of the word

and that seems self evidce in every language you that no

every other language

rests upon something called

common sense a common sense of your kind

some

why is that

because a word

what is the meaning of a word

what is the meaning of a word

the meaning of a word

is ultimately

not simply reducible to a string of other words

a meaning of a word is going to conjure associations

that are based on your sense and i'm going to clarify what i mean by sense

later

but the meaning of a word

conjures up a string of unconscious association

unwritten and unspeakable associations

that are ultimately rooted in your common sense

you're insect

this sense

is individual and particular

and and nonuniversal

non universal

what does that mean it means let's say'm speaking

polish there's a polish guy here right i'm in the polish countryside

i

the there's going to be the meaning of word

the meaning of a word in polish

is not going to be reducible to any kind of universal definition

there's some meanings of words that only other polish people are going to be able to understand

why is that

because

despite that everyone individually is different

and everyone individually

has different associations and meanings of words unconsciously based on their experiences and based on their background

the fact of the matter is that a nation

or a community or a local

tradition of some kind

for example

is based on a dialogue in a dialectic

of establishing by unwritten and unconscious means

common sense and common meaning

common meaning

it's like

all fu hold on sorry

on

ok

sorry what

common meaning and common sense

what this means

effectively

is that

this sight of meaning

must take into account what is unwritten

not just what it's written

but what's unwritten

what's unwritten

it's like how they say

you're either in the no or you're not in the

right

you either get it or you don't get it

when it comes to vernaculars

when it comes to languages

spoken in their everyday use

that's the case yeather get it or you don't

you get what it means or you don't

and i think

officially and medically speaking

some people say that people who have autism

have a really hard time

understanding unwritten and on

spoken meaning

and unconscious meaning

lock on had the very controversial view

that autistic people don't have it cononscious

for that reason

i

so i don't mean to offend people with the whole anglo autism box shit but

you know i'm not really that nice of a guy and it is what it is and

sorry

h i want to offend people

but that's what we're dealing with here oka

so

what does this have to do with dialectics

wellk one other thing

i just mentioned it's also based in sense

english

english

is unique in the fact

that it attempts to impose

a universal common sense preemptively

whereas other language couldn't convey meaning

and must accept

in good faith

that other people will just get it

english tries

to define the meaning preemptively

and contain the meaning in the word

against the void not against the determinate addressy

such as the person in your community

such as your countrymen

such as the people in your nation or in your community or in your localit or a definite other person

which requires

a dialectic of mutual engagement in the construction of mutual meaning

english rather arrogantly says

that

the meaning is already preemptitively defined and can be imposed universally

such that

to say a certain string of words

doesn't actually require determined address c

the word itself self contains

the meaning

quat the void

quae even something like

voic

it is meaningful even quad the void

how did have the english come to justify that

in this sense english is the first

modern language

the reason is because for them

they have reduced the deeper sense of words

the deeper unspeakable sense of words

to the empirical sects

to the empirical sense

to the literal

object

reducible to the five senses touch smell sight hearing

this is all you have to go on in the english language

empirical truth

plus

some kind of pre written

definition

these two things

for the for the english language supposedly

exhaust

the exhaust meaning

an analytic figure called rudolph carnap

critique tied to g precisely on these grounds

for him

empirical truth

and

discreet

predefined

definition

encompass and define the whole of human meaning the whole of human meaning can be reduced to

but most people

in the world

who do not have english as a secondary language

a

have as their primary sphere of communication

a somewhat criminal

a criminal language

they have a language which they know

can never be made

anunciable

and i

and directly apparent in the english language and they know that

if you're a secondary english speaker you know what i'm talking about

there's something subversive

there's something i

almost criminal

and off the books

about speaking in a non english

language

within a formal english setting

because engliand english has become

a global language

but the reason it's the global language

is because english is also a technical paradix

english is also a technical

there

i

it's what i mean by that is that english as the first modern language

doesn't have as its primary object

human conveyance of meaning

case

but some type of relation

to the inhuman

strange

let's just say technical

forces of production

that's why the english language

is so fick

in predefined

it's

peg

to a predefined

empirically air tight and absolutely

scientifically certain meaning

because this scientific certainty is operative

in modern technology

for example

born

formalistic modern

any

and modern form in general legal whatever

matt jane not really

well

poland is not based

well it depends on the context maybe within poland

it isn't the case because everyone just speaks polan

pull in that anyway

but i guarantee you if you're an immigrant in the united states

you're living in a polish community

you know your native polish language is going to feel criminal

innocence

with french there's a lot of context words a change meaning english

is really is more predefined with word

exactly

exact

youlook like baked alaska

know the

that is

it's like a food right

ok anyway

okay

why am i talking about language what does that have to do with dialect

well

etymologically

i don't know if i'm pronouncing it right etymologically

dialectics

dialectics

just responding to chat

oh

dialectics

i

sorry

dialectics

is

has its roots

in

dialogue

discourse debate

some type of

back and forth

conversation

sorry i just got a

i got a message on

witter

by

ing g

going to check out a thread

ok maybe i'll take it out

okay sorry about that detracting

my bengali is a heritage language speaker is not the same as

bengali bengali

interesting okay this is what dialectics mean though

i hope it sounds like that for you guys right doesn't sound like this

dialectic

they say for example

there's a local dialect

right you know what that means

dialect

and it's a language

it's a way in which things are spoken a local dialect

some kind of dialect

a variant

of a length

a formal language of some kind

dialectics etymologically has its roots in

dialectics discourse debate some other type of back and forth

conversation

ok

well let's start getting visual

and

do we pick on poor sage

do we pick on poorsage here

i'm not sure

here we have poor say

in ancient greece or something classical philosophy

and

i'm being very generous for how i'm drawing him

sage

speaks

and

another person

response

i know this is all really simplistics taking too much time to illustrate a very simplisty

point

but maybe some people like to see it vision

someone else

response

right

here

a dialectic

is initiated

why

why is something like a dialectic initiated

by this

by this encounter

right here

well let's

ignore

this

debator here

let's delete him

here's the question

who is the address

who is the address s

of sage's speech

this is a big miss

who is the addressy

of sages speech

when you speak

you convey meaning

with intention

you're trying to convey something meaningful to

ultimately to something

otherwise why speak

right

isn't there always a reason why you're going to expend effort

to speak

i

to say something

the question is

who is the address

of

some person speak

who is the address

well

this question mark

is always going to

result

in an address s

of some kind

who's going to give you knowledge

who's going to tell you something

that you didn't know

before

you

enunciated

before you engage

in the speech

you got a low everyone's leaving now

sorry red and don'tan s you later

my guys

y guys

i guess only enlight and w will

this okay

no whenever it doesn't matter who the addressy of speech is

sayus speech is

what every address see is going to have in common

otherwise there is no reason for any dialogue whatsoever is ultimately

this other

let's just call them the other

this other

is always going to have in common

the fact

that the other

is expected

to return to you

return to you

something that could not have premised

this speech

itself

no this is not from norm johms

ok

so

if it's a determinant other

there is no reason to speak to them

unless

and we're speaking what a very abstract

philosophical dialogue whatever

there's no reason to speak to someone unless you can

have the assumption

they're going to tell you something

that could not have premised

your speech

in relation to them

first

otherwise

otherwise

speech

is not communicative

it is not a dialogue

otherwise

otherwise

it's not a dialogue

but a form of domination

but a form of domination

if

you are absolutely certain

about the content of your speech

irrespective

of to whom it may be addressed

your goal is not

to receive something from the other

which could not have premised your speech

your goal is some kind of

domination

not just giving orders you can even be an s o s come please help me

but you're ultimately

you're ultimately exacting a result

you're trying to exact

a result

some kind

maybe i should not say domination i should say order

it's a it's a

it's order

right

it's an order

no i don't want to see what you

and

you keep using words without defining them

premised your speech what does that mean

ok g u n you linux

chill the fuck out

ok chill the fock out

premised your speech means

if it's a dialogue of some kind

then

whatever it is the other is going to return to you

could not be something that preemptively

premised the reasoning and the rationale

in your own head

and also the objective material causal reason

as to why you said it

they're going to give you a result

that is not only unexpected

but could not possibly have been premised in the original speech

you say a string of words you convey a meaning and they're going to tell you something

that in a sense surprises

that's what i mean

this sounds dumb to be honest

just trying to begin somewhere simple

isn't easy

thm

ok you can't use the word

in the definition

what are you talking about

what are you talking about g and you

like what do you mean you can't use the word in the what does that mean

explain to me what that means

explain to me what that means

ignore chat

and i want to help this guy

he's coming he's asking for help

what does he mean

the sage wants a fucking surprise

then why speak why engage in a dialogue of any kind

why why speak at all why speak at all

the question

why speak it all

so a premise that is not part of your argument

not a part of is doesn't go into your speech it's not going into the input

that rea that leads to the output of your speech

what i'm trying to say

no being shed the fock

people enjoying themselves are quiet

thanks

ok

basically what i'm trying to get at

this premis your speech mean

it was not a premise in your original argument no you're overthinking it

you're over i'm not saying a logical premise in your original argument i mean it objectively did not premise

the reasoning the cause the rationale

behind your speech

it did not objectively premise

your speech it was not part of the input that gave rise to your speech

in the first

game

i

has first s and then

oka ginzi

i get it

okay

jesus

premises a part of an argument premise conclusion

so much mean prochally

i didn't mention a fucking argument though but even then i disagreed

but even then i didn't say anything about an argument

ok i didn't say anything about an argu

sorry i'm sorry for getting mad i'm going to catch up with the chat ok sorry

let's delete all this

and

go back

okay

so what am i trying to get at

what am i trying to get into

i'm trying to establish

in the form of a dialogue let's say a socratic dialogue

where you guys not ae acradic a sign not a secratic

that's an example of one but

blatonic dialogue

plato was one athor

the way in which he develops his philosophy

plato

is that he has one guy

side

he has one guy

here

sound

copy that

pace that he has one guy

lip

was on

he is one guy

plato

right

plato is right here

he's the author one author

ok

he in

he's using both of these as his puppets right for his dialogue

why is he doing this

because plato

is developing his philosophy his dialectic

by having one guy say something right one guy's going to say some shit

and then another guy's going to say probably he's going to respond or he's going to say the exact opposite thing

through this plato recognizes

there is some kind of

outcome constructive out

why is that

why can't it just be a monologue of one guy talking

why is there necessarily an other

why is it necessary that for plato for example

could be anyone

there is necessarily an other who must say the opposite thing or respond

or respond

because

because

what's like

because

because

if it was just a monologue

has

search it spamming

i just

oky

sorry

then the hope you didn't expect anything special i mean your fused apply in anymore

in

to various programs

del what are you talking about

i think both views are too extreme so i don't discuss

them i didn't say that i thoundt think you're talking about

right you're not talking about me

sorry

okay

the reason it's not just a monologue

reiz the suckers didn't wrte

ok fine ginji i'll just focus on this

the reason it's not a monologue only a monologue and he needs

another person to say the opposite thing

to get it going

is because

for him

another person

let's say this guy

is giving embodiment

giving

giving expression

embodying

the necessary

ground of otherness

that

through a sity through which or for which or

upon

which

the truth

or essence

of the original

claim

can be clarified

ok this is a really big paragraph

truth were the essence of the original claim

can be clarified

when i say something

when i say something

or the person giving a monologue says something

ok

what up sky lethal

when you speak or say something

you don't necessarily know

what it is you are saying

remember what i said about anglo language

right

with anglo language

you are already certain as to the meaning

of what you're saying

here

here

your speech is addressed

to some kind of

absence some kind of emptiness

you speak something into existence

because you find it necessary to express some

but you don't know

what that something actually is

another person

who's initiating a dialogue or dialectue

for example

will give expression and embody

the ground of otherness

upon which

what you are trying to say

can actually be

revieal

because

and why is this

because

sid

at this

because

because

because

the

the ground that gives rise to the necessity

and even possibility of speech

cannot possibly be contained in the speech itself

this ground

right here

this is the ground of otherness i'm talking ab

this is the ground of

otherness

i am referring to

it is necessarily

outside of you somehow

it is other than you

right

try to explain the inadequaciy of an language in was not you could perfectly you have perfectly fine

um

it's just people are confused about what you mean when you use the

the problem

okay

this is the ground of otherness

that i'm referring to

the very ground that give rise to the necessity

and even possibility of speech

plato

for example

for example

gives expression

to this otherness

in the form of

a nother

first

ok

form of another person

alright

okay

what if i just established right now

i've established

maybe and this is not the best way to approach it

keep in mind i didn't have time to prepare for this in the law schooll bear with me

try to work with you guys

i started this out

with sage or someone

speaking

speaking

what have i done here though

i've created a contrast of some kind

you have a person

with an output

for example

out

you have an output

some kind

and then

you have another

have another

so i'm not going to

going to do this

and then you have

some type of otherness

that reveals the truth

review of the truth

of the input

the input

truth

i' say truth in' want to say s

will reveal the truth

of the input

when you speak of something else directing your speech something in you ok let's not get there outyt

will reveal the truth of the in

some other

some type of other

other

some type of other

he doesn't know

because

why is this

why

because

because

because

he doesn't

no

because he doesn't know

the input

because he cannot

contain

the input

that premises his speech

in the

output

he cannot

i need to make this small

s it's

cannot contain the input that premises his speech

in the output

at least so far as he know

not

he's so far as he knows

fork man i wanted to make it small okay

and i know this is shitty and complicated but this is he

see this he cannot contain the input that premises his speech

in the output as far as he

nos

this other

is going to reveal to him something

that

that could not

as far as he knows

premise

his output

that's why he speaks an output in order to discern

what he himself is trying to say

can we get some background music

turning on

like a university lecture

and this is so hard

so haart

let's let's this

world is back and know this is not a good start i n not i'm not doing a really good job here

but

let's just roll this back a little bit

let's ust roll this back a bit and i want to start

with something maybe you're

more familiar

let's think

let's roll this back

ok let's roll this back

sorry i'm not doing a best job

let's roll this back

to metaphysical dualism

right

metaphysical

dualism

metaphysical dual

okay

now this is something you guys are probably familiar with right

in metaphysical dualism

cross the history of humanity

cross the history of humanity

you've got what

you've got this union unan thing

going on

you guys probably

are familiar with

fuck me man i can't stand this

ms p

bullship

that

sorry

yet

this thing going on

and then just because i'm going to be af

jesus

that you go

i

it

what

you got this

and then you've got

something you probably

haven't heard of manykiani ism

nethianism

you got ggnosticism

you've got all sorts of dualisms

o

you're right it's diff

i know what we're going to get through this truss we're going to get through

i get it somewhat i'm ted don't worry don't worry about he going look on right now

i don't

i'm going to try i'm trying to make this as simple as possible but that's why it's so hard

can you get a fucking powerpoint make this beforehand

damnl the promise i can'

like i just got out a class before i

did the stream

and i have wrote a paper yesterday

tuesday so i'm bogged down with law school right now

until i can escape law school

i'm not going to

we'm going to try to make i'm going to try to work on the imperialism one maybe a week ahead of

slowly add to it and work

p

but

yeah dude

s

psychanalism

for second

spent learning it's five ten spend

writing i hope so u

okay

yeah very true

okay

there's metaphysical dualism you're probably familiar with this right there's yin and yang monikanism gnosticism

and there's all sorts of dualities you're going to find across history and various mythologies

and all that kind of bullshit you're going to find

that the world is being represented in opposites right

being the world the universe

whatever

is represented

in the form

opposite

i hope you guys are familiar

right

in the form of opposite

o

the way most people interpret this

the way most people

interpret this

is to

metaphysically positive

entities

that contradict one and another

ok

for example

here

i want to ask you the chapter question

no i'm not going to start with value

has i guys i want to ask oh fuck

alexander just remind me

fouht

this is this is the most important

anchor point

for all of this

this one right here

all the gods

this is the most important one

sexual difference

man woman masculine feminine

this is the primary

means by which

ah

metaphysical dualism

is uh

is given expression in relation

set some kind of sexual

can beliave i just forgot

see how folkinghuf this is for me

yup so okay

i want to begin here

right here

radio

most people i want to ask you the ch at the question

why is to

so privileged

across the history of human civilization

and

in general why is there metaphysical dualism

now

in most

in today's universities

you have

a a

two

you have a

an attack against binary logic

binary lodge

bye

favoring

favoring pure multiplicity and pure diversity

instead

because for them

because for them

the binary is just

one

is the binary for them is just one plus one

so they asked a simple question

why must there be one plus one

when we can have one plus one plus one plus one plus one

why one why not two why i sorry why two why not three why not four why not five

why not six for example

this is the basic and then you're going to see this kind of

logic expressed in other places even in physics

what do you have you have a

many worlds theories

and then analytical philosophy you have another type of many world

a oll there's many possible languages in many possible worlds and many possible whatever

you know it's like it's this

privileging of

multiplicity

right

clear privileging of multiplicity

over bindary

over bind

one second

okay

s

but the fok is wrong with this camera

back

back

on

no forgive but you i don't mean to like b you

okay

or delos i don't mean to like that

just in a commonsensical way you know i want to

have the least barrier entry

to this

right

okay

least spirit entruy possible

everyone is probably familiar with this

all of you are probably familiar with this

can i get a one in the chat if you're familiar with metaphysical dualism

you heard of the in yan

you know about

the way in which opposites

are used

to give expression as the most primordial state of being

you know there's

two different

two opposites that define

being right

and then the wld man women

binary logic

one of the chat if you gys understand this

so far

because i can i can get into it a little more

and give you more examples in illustrate more example

everyone gets it

that's

awesome

everyone seems to understand

okay great great great goat great got it

ok thank you we have to dwell more on this

okay

now i want to focus your attention now

on this little box and we're going to save this box

when we while we delete everything else

and we're going to

going to save this box

the way most people interpret metaphysical dualism

is two positive entities that contradict each other

so you got a one

ok sorry going to do

you've got

one

i

plus

one

well that is arbitrary isn't it

why not three

why not

four why not five

why too

why too

why too

well i'll tell you what

this is a big miss

this is a big misunderstanding

of both metaphysical

both

sorry

there

both

the origin of

why metaphysical dualism is so prevalent

and why

a and

what

the unity of opposites

relevant to dialectics is

ok

this is a big misunderstanding

um

yeah the mind body difference daniel that's a really big one

my mind body dualism is

one you guys are probably familiar with as well and that's also just sext engendered right body is female and mind is masculine

you got the logos and you have sophia

you have all sorts of different

that's gnosticism and all that kind of stuff

the mind body one

is i think

i think it's

very prevalent across the stree of humanity but it's given

fullest expression i think

through gnosticism and then

gnosticism culminating in de cart

and that's what's critiqued as binary logic

the universe

and so on

that

but this is what i want to focus your attention on

it is not

that metaphysical dualism

is arising out of an arbitrary imposition

of two just privileging two ones

because in that case

in that case

why not three why not four why not five why not six

yeah base where suberz was another one

which is also why

in most ways people use base for superstructure it's un dialect

i me

i'll explain that more later

but

let's

get rid of this

here's what we need to keep in mind

mister

dialectics

it always begins with one

dialectics is actually monotheistic

it so controversial on the shit i'm going to say

sorry

always begins with one

maybe i should

deemphasise this a little bit so as to not confuse you guys

but i'll clarify what i mean by it

but i want to emphasize that

dialectics it always begins with one

there is always a striving

and in orientation

to what is ultimately

one

seeing

one

see

seeing

t

too

to is merely

the most initial

the most initial

primordial

and immediate

expression given to a difference that is

that

experience

proper to

one

you've got one thing first

you've got one thing

first

you understand

you've got one thing first

towo merely is the most initial

expression given to the fact

that

here's where i'm going to say

the form

subtantiation

and

box

f you will

if you will

we give to oneness

will always necessarily enter into contradiction with its real cont

actual and real content

there is some kind of difference

metaphysical dualism

is never actually an arbitrary unity of two ones

it's always trying to give expression to this

primorial distinction if you will

between simple distinction

between no

guys this is another issue we're going to have with these education stream

is that you're looking for the

you're looking for

who i'm referencing and you're looking for

which authority this is citing

but i am just trying to get you guys to think about this independent

you know don't worry about

how i'm arriving

don't worry about who's the background

i'm not talking about me i'm not talking about bedu right now

i'm not talking about jk right now

ok let's think actively

instead

let's just think actively

right let's try to think of it independently

so it is like multiple conflicting dedities being merged into one super

i don't know how you're

you're drawing the

i don know how youre drawing

i just said

you begin with one

ok

now

the multiple

it' is a different story right now but you begin with one

when you're concerned with dialectics in the abstract

always because the only reason there's a unity of opposites

the only reason you privilege opposites

because you're dealing with one

and its otherness

one and its other names

its own otherness

this other ness is that one

you understand

this otherness

proper to the one

is the one

is strange from itself

somehow

the form and the content

for example

being what is so funny

and you you being what is so funny what's so funny

i'm trying really hard

ok

what's so funny tell me what's so funny

is this like the essence of something and the appearingce

sure that's another way of putting

the essence in the appearance

isn't dragging

your use of trigger words

very

okay

one and it's otherness yes that's how you should put it

one and its otherns

one and its others

ok

now why do we begin with one

why does one begin with one

i just said it

i just said why

because

why begin with one

because one begins with one

one person begins

side one

thinker

subject individual

the mind begins with one

so once you put something into a box it's no longer reality it's the science about it's no longer what's really happening

the model

no don't worry about that

ok

i'll get to what the box is

no way of putting that is the opposite discloses something about the one

yes

yes

pin that comment

yes

very true

very much what i'm trying to get at

begins with one

we are instand sheated in a determinant

singular way

terminated

singular way

fuck i lost the textbox i can't ad

singular way

singular way

our object

is always one

one

s always one

fok this textbox man

god fucking damn pain

in so far as

our speech

our thoughts

are mine

etcetera

etcetera

is determint

and itself singular

what up kangaroo what's up

in mathematical optimization theory duality is the principle that

optimization problems may be viewed from

either of two perspectives the primal problem of the dual problem

the one defines the opposite

i'm not that familiar with that

i

gotta go what se later ageent chaos

i

okay

why begin with one because one

is determin it singular way

our object is always one insaviars our speech our thoughts our mind is determinate and itself

singular

in a sense ontology

is mano fiust

itself

when we ask what is being

we're asking what is something

what is a something that something is ultimately

implied as one something one being

one being right

being itself

confronts us as one thing

and even when we divide it into several things

that's only in so far

as thouseh several things

is those several things

those several things

bear witness to the fact

that there cannot just be one

there's multiple

because there cannot

just be one

for example

oh

german is the more

voice in reality english

okay

and

i want to clarify this about metaphysical dualism

the difference between masculine and feminine

in contrast to what they teach you in the american universities

for example

there's no transforbia

on my part i'm not like paul cock shot or whatever

but i'm going to just say this

because anyone who's saying otherwise is lying

this difference between

metaphysical dualism between masculine and feminine

is giving rise

is the very expression for example of a dialectic between form and content

between

night and day

for example

darkness and light

body in mind

on

these distinctions are proper to every human civilization

now

there

all human other civilizations do have

a sense of multiplicity and so on

but

this multiplicity

is ultimately

i

is ultimately

coming from

branching out

from this original

and

man vers woman is in dialect

ok but you know what i mean

gentle

you know what i mean i mean masculine

how much i need to smoke to understand this

i don't

i

metaphysical dualism is trying to give expression to one thing

ultimately one thing which is being

it is not an arbitrary

privileging

to

for no reason

it is trying to give expression to one thing

being

being itself

okay

so

who is our original one

we began

initially

with someone

trying to

one person with one

y

okay

otherness is negative

i'm not exactly sure of that

hold on i'm getting some d m s and tweets

shit

sorry

using what

okay

sorry

sorry okay

bro just read hayel easy

okay

we're back

we began with one person speaking to one

address

but there's other ways

to

to situate the contrast

between

the basic contrast that initiates a dialect

what is ok let me

go back a little bit and just say

we can now see

we should now be able to understand very simply that a dialectic

is some kind of interaction some kind of encounter

between two opposites

a one and its other

the object

of dialectic

unifies them both

as ultimately

one

the

what are other examples of this encounter between

um

some type of one

a subject

so i'm talking au as sub

some type of one and it's an other nis

ok

for example

for example

we have

a person

and their address se in this case

maybe this is a crazy person

their addresse in this case

isn't

another person

but his nature

nature

nature for example

and

nature for example means what

it means

same thing

has another vegan in the shat

you got it

you if you hear my views on animal rights you'll stop you'r unsubscribe

not sure if you want

um

if you're a vegan and you hear my word

and you hear my views on animal rights you are going to

decribe

sand

promise you that

i

speaking with one addressy

this

that' sure this is the best example i

okay

this is another example

this is another example of anotherness

another example

of others right here

another example of otherness

ah

okay

this is another example

nature

guys by the way if you're not following

say something in the chat

any of this sounds arbitrary and doesn't isn't clicking

ah

isn't

clicking light bulbs and just kind of making sense of things just say so and i'll try to change my p

like i said i need feedback i need know where you guys are

right

because the shit is not easy

i

another example otherness is nature itself

ok

now

here's something else i want to say

i know this kind of schitzoism all over the place

in a way

in a way dialectic

you

has been the default for the entire

entire history of humanity

for the entire history of humanity there is

always a sense of the unspeakable

sublime

m

said to the otherness a conditions

that conditions the possibility of

uh meaning

speech reason

sir

okay

yuh

but

only after anglo saxon modernity and

saxon medith

does the

dialectic

of being become foreclosed

foreclosed

only here is there a striving to arrive at

what

at one this

at the object

in e

as reducible to one form

and premised by one

universal

self subsistence

and absolutely self search and for

why is that

why is this

not just like what is the reasoning behind me saying this but why did it actually happen in reality

no i don't get why the opposite doesn't do the same thing for the one

not not

the opposite

what a thing is

not

discloses something positively

because

within the standpoint

of a single person a single subject a single speaker or single s

thinker

mm

what

you are

what your being is for example

is not known to you

is only revealed to you by means of the other

the other is the site at which what you are

can be revealed

to you

why do you guys think people go on the internet

and seek attention

because we don't know what we are

fundament

we search for other people

to

to reveal what we ourselves are

that's why we go on the internet

and we type on lefty poole

for example

even though we're anonymous

because we want to type something and we want to see how people are going to respond to it

and

that's going to reveal to us what we are

because we don't know what we are

should i be thinking in terms of electroardes but no don't worry about that that's way too metaphysic

don't worry about

that kind of stuff

but i'm already veel to myself

that is my ego but what is your ego

for example what is the content of ego

and in terms of theky and thinking you just equated angle with the process of foreclosure which is to say psychos

gentle g ge

i'm doing it intentionally

according to lacon

normal

experience of normal reality

which i interpret as

experience of

modern normal life

does result

from

foreclosre is a primordial form of

coast

yes

i know that

and i say that intentionally

there's also heidegger's foreclosure of being

think which is what i'm aiming at a little bit more the foreclosure of being

itself

the question of being being itself becomes

foreclosed and we only can speak now of

that particular being

being as such becomes foreclose to us as something that reveals itself in a novel

and the unique were

ah

okay

okay

to proceed now

to proceed now

is it is theres a more refined version of taoism

well i would argue that the world's religions in general have this as their object

not the other way around

it's not that i'm trying to reproduce

world religions in the past i think these world religions have this

i

contradiction

defining being itself as there are

including tism which is more explicit about that but also every other religion including

ones that are not

unnecessarily dualistic metaphysical

you should explain what foreclosed means

foreclose in the sense of the

the ceiling off

ceiling off

closing off

right

ceiling off

ceiling off

a

closing of

h okay

okay

oh

right

so

we can accept

we can recognize

recognize

a simple

a simple difference

proper to oneness

something and it's other

form and content

i think is and it's actual content

form some thing is

and its actual content

for exact

but what makes

but

how does it come to pass that the object of dialectic is itself revealed as one thing one

site

one uh disclosure of me

ok this is the

topic

question

that i want us to

focus our attention on

i have nott psychosis in the past this mean i'm

wee closed

well

that's why i don't want to talk about lek on

you know

people over

is interpreted in a psychiatric way

and over identify with

why are you on the infrared stream for example interesting

question alexander is going with the deep question okay

let's focus our attention on this

we can recognize a simple difference proper to ones something

and its other

the form of what something is and its actual cont

but how does it come to pass that the object of

dialectic is itself revealed as one thing

one disclosure of being

well

why don't we relate this to this issue of socialism

why are most people socialists

what does socialism mean for example

for most people

it means

here i am

here i am

for example

this is a contradiction isn't it

i'm here i'm sad

and

shey world

right isn't that the case shitdy bad world

everything sucks

and here i am

and i'm sad

about this

ok

is this a contradiction

isn't this

what we're talking about

when we're talking about bread to

and we're talking about the entire aesthetic of socialists in twenty twenty one

doesn't this ltimately though

um

doesn't this ultimately

imply a type of arrogance

isn't this also kind of arrogant

higgle

a guy you're probably a little familiar with the name

he referred to this aesthetic

as the aesthetic of a romant

the romantic

a or the let's say the romantic

is an aesthetic

of the unhappy consciousness

the unhappy consciousness

according to hagel

is an initial encounter with the fact

that

move this year

an issue

initial encounter

with the fact

that the inner cef

andrs

radically enters

into contradiction with the outer world

being unable to

being unable to find

full expression and

this is the most important

so what does the socialist do and say

socialists say this is a shitty world

and how do they arrive at the conclusion that a chity world

because the world does not reflect

what they what is within them

the world does not reflect

the striving in their inner striving to be realized

in the world

instead they're confronted with a contradiction

and they're confronted with

uh imperfection or whatever right

yes gentle gin gy

exactly it's the beautiful soul we're talking about

ok

the socialist says

the solution to this

is to change the world

solution to this

the world must be

itself be changed

so what is going to happen now am i going to be jordan peterson and say no you have to change

mm

clean your own bedroom

for you

clean your own bedroom before you want to change the world buckle

maybe you just got to change

your outlook

but

although

i'm not going to get into jordan peterson

time

jigle

arrives at something that superficially

might sound a little similar to this

jordan peterson

for hagel

the problem with

this socialist right here

who bases their entire aesthetic and their identity upon the fact

upon this initial encounter with a contradiction

initial content

contradiction

i

hagel says

what

this person cannot see is how

this contradiction

sorry this looks so bad

this contradiction

from here on out

every line you see like a dash like this this is a contradiction

right

this is the difference itself the contradiction

for hagel

for hagel

is actually proper

proper to the very object

the world

itself

what does that mean

what does that mean

it means this

the anglo socialists you are familiar with on bread tub and on youtube

they are this guy

they think this is a shitty world

and the goal is to change the world and that sense not in marx the sense but in their sense right

special sense

they're elevated above the world

they know better in their head

ah the truth whole truth of being

simply because they have encountered

a contradiction

but the contradiction is still

the contradiction

is still

purely subjective

oh boy

this is such a mess

but this is still a purely subjective contradiction

the only source of the contradiction here

the only source of the contradiction here

the only source of the contradiction here is the fact

that the world

does not conform

to what the socialist feels

is within their very soul

but what hegel says

according to hagel

what hegel says

is that to recognize the contradiction

as itself

objective

means

that

you recognize the difference the contradiction

as proper to the thing itself

not just something that dwells inside of your heart

but is actually proper to the object itself

the object

the wound is already reconciled

this is what hegel means

by the wound on the cross

we only see the world as shitty

but we do not include in the world

the very contradiction

that we experience

in a purely subjective way

if we did include the contradiction

that we experience purely subject

as a feature of the object

solf

paradoxically

this is the source of an immense reconciliation

why is that

because

true

because for hegel for example

christ for hegel

this for hegel

deliverance to the true object

is the source of true

subjective

freedom

let's say absolute knowledge

when we recognize the contradiction as proper to the object itself

and not just something

that

a

that is instantiated

subjectively as the difference between ourselves

and the world

we put the contradiction to work

we see the contradiction as the object itself and we see

we see it as something

w which is the source of a continued development

some kind

the contradiction sets in motion

the beginning

of work

the beginning of work

beginning of work

why

i got to clean this mess now

explain why

and i'm going to save this

little

arrangement

get rid of it to

so i can

bring it back

make it small

why

much

au

mo

make it

is good ac

right but this year

okay

um

why is there reconciliation

because

this

both thing

comes proper

to the object

proper to the world

the object

contradiction

well if i ck a twenty inch dick there's nothing gon do to pursue this so how do i cope

gues elien subjected stitution

perfect danswer

contradiction what is the implication of this

the implication is simple

the implication is simple

the object the world society

is no longer taken

were expected to be

a

whole form

the deviation from which

was the prior source of this appointment and

unhappiness

contradiction

is

rather

recognized as a feature of the object itself

that's placing the subject

on a new

footing

that is delivered to

that is delivered

to a relation

to the world

how should relation to the world

it was ver defined by

the active

its own active

development

the dialectic of freedom and necessity

this is kind of

all about aesthetics this turn

went from language to aesthetics

such a long paragraph too

so anything that you pursue is your other even if it is something in an ideal self of some kind

not necessarily the other is going to be the objective

response you're going to get

in that pursuit you're going to pursue for example an ideal self

and reality is going to spit out something completely different

than what you expected to be your ideal self

that is the expression of

other

it is only when there's a response to you

that

and other

your stream is covering

the box

ango box nine

if i accept i will always be lacking in anything then why pursue anything

well what is the object of that you can pursue if you recognize the it's not that you will always be lacking danvil

it's that the object itself is lack

the object itself

and why is it lacking it's only lacking from a subjective perspective

in axual reality

the object

is positive

in such a way

that you subjectively experience it as lack

but this subjective experience results from a feature an objective material feature

proper to the object itself

feel this s makes much more sense it was another

language th english

i don't expect you guys to get this right off the bat this is just an intro

and it's not the best intro

possible

but i want you guys to take something away from it

something

nice

i just saw that nice

i just saw that link in g nice

um

now now you guys can see wen a deeper german idealis perspective why i say we're living in socialism partially the reason why i say we're living in socialism

is because

i want to combat

would ginji rightly recognized as would hegel called the beautiful soul

i want to combat this

aesthetic of socialism

you see

this aesthetic of socialism

if we say we're already living in socialism

and

so the meaning of we already live in

this way

the meaning of

the meaning of we already live in

socialism

is that

socialism is no longer

confined to a little

box in our heads

forever set against the world

the very contradiction

that gives rise to our socialistic

subjectivity is recognized to be proper to the object the world itself

hence the

the world is

already

so

that's what i'm right

see

if you have terminal angle brain rot no

it's not going to make sense at

nice i'm going to come back and watch this when later thanks for the good work see later sopprilette

apreciate you being here

s later

and

but su

so i got some

got some

m

so

patients

on

ge

this year this year this ok

sorry

alright

oh i'm covering it sorry

covering it again with the fok

there's no way to win except if i disappear

see this

okay

i don't remember anything i read that's one symptom

that's ok it's ok

i just want to introduce you a little bit

to

the dialect

this

initiates

right here

putting it onto the object itself

initiates re initiates

the dialectic process

what's called in marxist terms unleashing the forces of production

you become subjectively attuned

a

to dialectic of freedom and necessity

and you become delivered

to this

process of the unleashing of the forces of production

i have a long journey to go don't worry about a lot of people take years and years to understand

you know

and i'm trying to condense a lot

you love this lecture cabins luicious thanks man

like i said i didn't have time to prepare for this and a lot of this is coming off the top of my head

and i'm trying to take into account what i would expect you guys to be at

that's why it's just

i'm stumped a lot you know because this

thinking about what i would should i say you know and what will make the most sense

i

okay

a

okay

i'm glad ginje ginjit

like knows exactly what i'm talking about here you know

he's very educated and well read and

so he knows exactly what i'm talking about i'm just trying to

try to make the best way to make it

understandable to you guys

alright let's

let's continue

okay now

exactly spikey exactly

exactly exactly yes you get it

you get it

um okay

okay

dialectics

i want to try and work with your guys as associations when you see this word dialect

above all what you should be thinking about

above all

you should be thinking about

when you see this word

th

is

the tit for tag

hahh tids

it's it for tat

the back and forth the the

the movement

of something

to its opposite nothing

and back

oh

inscribed

oh

proper

to one object

ultimately

one object itself

a dialectic

re first

tin movements

that every form

every discreet

four

and tangible form necessarily

enters

into contradiction

with

its own conditions of existence in a way that cannot be preemptitively defined known or contained within the form itself

i know this is not that helpful because i'm just typing paragraphs and shit

and i'm not doing enough visual illustrations you know

so maybe i should do that

and on being off topic here

but when i hear the word dialectics firsting comes to my mind is different sandings of dialect

western vers easn marxs had which it self is dialected absolutely absolutely

guys

all of this comes together

ok

the east vers west difference is a dialect

the rule versus urban is a dialect

town versus country

a dialect

mind versus body is a dialect

i

marxist materials dialectic means there's a unity of opposites

so it is a search for

grounding these

contradiction

such a way

so as to arrive at their objectivity

their objectivity

contradiction is itself

syriaus

maateial

contradiction is itself what is material

that's why i speak of substantialism as anglo saxon seventeenth century metaphysm

within substantialism

the thing that is material is already a predefined form of some kind

it's a tangible object in the clickal sense of our words

it's an object like this water bottle

it's an object like an apple it's already a predfined form

but

the object relevant for dialectics

serialus dialectics

what is so material about the object

is not the fact

that it is sensuously

real

only sensuously real

but that

the

contradiction

reveals itself

as objective

as objective

in a way

that cannot be contained

for example in a previous grounding of the dialect

the example of this is hagels dialect

hagel's dialectic attempted

to ground the very

subjective

appreciation of

dialectic itself

in ultimately one form

one form

that

philosophy through philosopy

marx simply

continued to dialect

he said hegel

a can't you see

that in this movement

of arriving at absolute knowledge

having exhausted the whole extent of

philosophy

the movement of philosphy

you have merely arrived

and um

commanded

you will

a

compelled

an encounter

with the otherness

in actual reality that is

proletarian

proletariat

is the concrete

disclosure

of a unity of our

namely and this is kind of separate

dialectics

proletaria

so i

pletarian

a concrete manifestation

of a contradiction

and what is this contradiction

what is this contradiction

the actual living

expression of what hegel

arrives at

in thought

as the unity of opposite

and not being

okay

philosophers only interpret the world ver is the point is change it

needs trolling

as usual

the actual living expression of what he gol arrives

at in thought

primarily

a scandal for philosophy since

since

it

the bases

he he

the

philosophies universal state

man

as premised by thought

four

as citizen

proletariat

is a hole in the edifice

of hegolian

universal stateh modern

statehood in gener

proletary the one

productive relations

the other

n know the proletariat then though this is where we must escape

the one sidedness

of merely recognizing the dialectic in the form of a contradiction

and recognize the contradiction itself to be object

which means

our object is no longer one or the other

our object is the very essential

contradiction

for which

the distinction between one and other

is a secondary expression

subjectively

meaning

the proletariat is itself a concrete unity of o

the proletaria is itself the concrete

unity of our

the unity of opposites

i

between

between what

from the perspective of the universal state which attempts to premise man

by some kind of form

citizen

the citizen

the proletariat is the living contradiction

the unity of opposites

between man

between man and his material actual

sensuous

this

marks

and living reality

and

the modern form

of citizens

this is the unity of opposites that defines the proletariy

this is the unity of opposites defining the politary

right the other is the citizen and what is the other ness of the citizen

for hagel

for hagel

the other nis of the citizen

for example

is the void

form for hagel arises forth

from the void

for marks

form does not arise from the void

form arises from some type of material content which cannot be preemptively known in thought

were subjectively

but which is nonetheless

real and material and object

and in a sense

in a sense

the busze was state

for example

form of the buszis state

arises in contradiction to

what

the peasant

right the the rule countryside

ven d whatever

the proletariat is the living and concrete manifestation

of that contradiction

as

living in

persist

that's why marx's privileges the proletariat and not the peasant

mark's privileg is the proletaria

because

for marks

the dualism

of the modern bourgeoisie

a and

and and

the cities and the mass would marks cause the mass of

the rule poor

for example

this contradiction

does not reveal anything to us about

what is

objective in being

so

it's a one sided contradiction

right

it's not enough we need the proletaria

disclose the fact that the contradiction is itself something that

is object

and it's not just

dwelling in a subject

who recognizes difference

between town

with a mass of the rule poor

and the

i

so yeah

okay um

think i'm going to start taking questions

we're really kind of going down in viewers even though we peeked at eighty which is falcking crazy

fucking crazy

but this is probably a good time to just start taking

quest

unless you guys want me to explain some more stuff

that i

then maybe i'll think of more things

that i wanted to say that i forgot about

what did i want to say

oh

i don't know this is the intro this isn't going to be the last educational stream about dialect

maybe i'll say that say this

i

i will be

much more

want to get the ball

and get you guys

in new way

that

x

sorry if i disappoint

i can do more but i just need your feedback a little more because at this point

i need to think a little more about

what i should say

it's just an interest

you know

senior

it'sjust my best attempt at it in

and i can already see the lefty pol comments in do to bd look a stupid it remember guys next stream

give me what you think i should address and respond to and i only address that

not

the lefty pull ups don't care about this hegel onan on one

has would you yes i'll invent i'll invite you gentle

g

via twitter

i' going to invite

okay

let's have

injee

our guest

speaker

enter the building

see

invite

copy invitely

we're going to invite our guests

speaker ginj

ok i'm going to exit out of paint

we don't be so harsh on yourself we just want

so wew you got adjust your shit

we don't need a one to one weeed a zero zero one yeah

yeah

there's just some shit in my head that i wanted to say that i forgot about

you know

okay

i just forgot about a lot of

you know

okay

just invited you

i just invited ginji

my bt are you banned from the top set no dude i didn't ban anyone no one's banned in our chat

nobody but nobody's banned in the chesck

nobody's been

we don't do that over here guys we don't ban

we don't do that over here

i'm right back

i'm very bad

be right back sorry

let's see we don't have anybody in the

ihoudvent why did'

you have to do that schizo energy

that's just facts the good in the bad that comes with it

yeah dude it's off the top of my head to you know because of this law school bullshit

poor housjust realized the western left has been more folked than he thought and he had lowt e pis expectations

possible

i've always known that dude

ah

okay

engage in a dialectic with this video

hm

but

oop something went wrong meete that video link doesn't work

video link doesn't work

i want to drop out of law school thats honestly i want to drop out

but

you know i got to secure my future but i hate i fucking hate law school do i feel it's a waste of time

i fuck and hated dude

i hate it so much

you have no idea

i wish i could do this shit full time not i'm not just talking about streaming but also writing

you know

and studying and doing all this

full time

i fuck in a law school

works on my machine

send the link again i need a

another link

yeah i mean you don't get to choose how you make a living you know all jobs a

and this at least law school gives me time to

do this

you know

hes youar

what up genje

was sub ginji

your mike is really bad really bad mike

i'm going to mute you i muting is here

hold on

took terrible mike to

terrible mind

school of life hob

your mike's really bad it's really bad it's like

your mike's really bad u

where can you find your writings bro

i want to know what i should really i want to know like who my audience is first you know

and then i'll

i'll release stuff

i'll tailor my stuff

to toward my audience

i never i never write things to to whom they may be concerned i always write for a purpose and for a context

and for an audience

you know

ah

me tell there's a problem is my

i just told her

what who did marx write for

marx had an audience in mind

he wrote for the new york tribune

and most of marx's work were published

after his death by angle

for the workers movement that existed at

so mark didn't write to whom it maye

either

you know if i'm going to be paid for my wriuntings i'll write to whom maybe that's what it's for guys

writing for to whom it may be concerned is for getting paid that's why sesic

releases twenty books a year and they're all the same thing

because he just wants to make money and i need to make money too don't be wrong the's nothing wrong with

but

if i'm going to have a targeted audience and i'm doing it for free

i don't want to waste my time or your

ginji theres a lot of

so how should riight for american pools we're not there yet

noo ca you

lucoking bad

are you his ster

life in the sahart

america's a lot bigger than germany re marxs alive true and there's also the fact that

the workers movement was a lot more concrete than

whatever we're going to define as america

cause why is dialectic relevant

that's a really good question

it's relevant because the let the all the lefs problems stem from one sidedness

you know

in any subject is they get too caught up one sidedly and they never see the bigger picture of

what the contradicts

y

can't believe we have fifty viewers watching

that's what jen said it's a

sandtorm man returns

it's like technical difficulties extreme technical difficulties

hm

and

so hiy

oh

trying and play you the microphone ginji

mayb you call your phone weill fix this guy he's going to fix it

i'm just reading some shit that's funny

not going to show it to you guys though i was going to laugh to myself es can watch me laugh

than you

i'm just waiting forhim to join

so i'm i'm reading that pull thread guys pull throread is actually kind of funny

yeah i'll do a i think i'll do that

i don't know

i think the next one' is going to be about imperialism and i' want to put a new poll on our twitter

so you guys can vote about it

i'm so i'm fascinated by this let me see if there's any porn

here n the is n

i'm reading this pull thread gt as'm fulking fascinated by

the

oh it's not in the right one

he's here

can ge here

it

no i can't hear you

s ba

e

jesus

n the it's not work

i i can usly do i can

i can

i'm was going to show the chat this fortune thing

i can't hear you i can't hear you

i can i'll tell you when i can hear you i can't hear you so far

i just can't

i'll tell you when i can hear you ok

ok

im you to do

okay

check the sit out do

these people like me more than left people

and guess what dude sages heyar what a pussy

and look where he lives

thenight s and i say he's a fucking angle you i told you

i told you dude

i told you

interesting th these people

i don't know if i want to read all this

dude

interesting

okay that's an interes

threat

all right

going to go make dinner nice stream you'd see later jimmy

subjenial o'higgins

what

all right

do have link to the thread

someone should make sage mad

sorry i'm be behind with the stream i would like to ask you ginji younplaan the proter and his unity opposite thing

sure

the proletariat is the unity of opposites the opposites being

the form of the modern citizen and the actual real

humanity

for example as a pito myze by the peasants

the working humanity the material humanity economic humanity

protary is the unity of o

it's not simply just the peasantry

to be one sided

the unity of the opposite itself

the only thing i could see in that third was a craiglist for

for

here

and white noise and come in

no

jesus

i was so loud

somebody should have told you this hoe was sage is something anyone can name theselves or not the bump

thread

if you think a thread doesn't deserve to live you save you

oh ok

i don't i'm not familiar with the lingo not familiar with the terminology

you know

screen is frozen

know the screens just frozen

screezes frozen

our angle brains can't understand g

i don't know what's going on dude

oh my god

stay way too long

taking way longer than it should

on

he's here but i

he's joining

there's a so patient guys i've just been fucking browsing shit

today

such a bad streamer

all right i'm going to browse it with you guys

ginjy dude i can't keep

i can't keep up with this dude

you know

we got at some point i got to give the chat something

some content

you know

let me just tell gjit this

you know i got to

i got to give chat something to watch

you know i can't

have you guys just

watch me brows the in

waiting

has opinion on anglo music

actually don't really like it

honestly i

i like irish music

what is your favorite dinosaur

the

to

fucking tricetops not what's the one with the fucking

the the horns and shit

whatever that one is

speaking what up chris what em tok con git haven't seen ahim onstream

i don't know dude i just sent him a d m on twitter that i got a

we got to get the show on the road you know

you got to continue the streams got to continue this is been

way too long we've been

do enough

i want to hear can you dout meet

me too

but this needs to be fixed

i don't know what's been going on

this needs to be fixed

this must be fixed

right

trying to be optimistic

trying to be optimistic in this is in work

trying to be optimistic

lut of dinosaurs have horns

what is i think it's a trice tops ory trice sera tops

ya it's a tried syrup tochops

i like that one

think

think i like that one the most

isn't it weird how triy sarahtops

is a

is it tri saratops a

reptile is not folking weird it's like the strangest reptile

that's ever existed

is it a reptile

they are stupid

no it's not a reptile

wait is it reraptile i don't fuck in the

shit

maybe that's pre the classification of

reptiles

try this and critique it

ok

oh it's not working

neeeds your links don't work for some reason

sen send me the link on twitter

send me the link on twitter

send me the link on twitter

all dinosaurs are reptiles right

a bird

dinosaurs were ripped

howo dude were they

searchrack seting this call and it's still not reinstalled

my fokingal was

ok need sent me a philosophy parade ot of gvery gun and in a parade

god damn it how fucking annoying are these ads i hate

fox

s

tuck up

nw

hate that so much

okay

we're go to watch a hegl video

we're going to lower the desktop

audio a little bit

and

okay

alright this is what needs centres i know i'm using my webss

that

you read quihy noe never heard of white people are the only people we invented civilization

has is part of the non people that thinks he can steal my personal wealth

what a cot

ok filthy

ok

ok dude

filthy i saw that copy post that you posted on my channel

i just saw it today

nice

guys don't critique my computer because i'm going to buy a new one soon and i'll do everything good on that computer when i get this new computer i'm going to do restream

i'm going to

have excellent quality streams i go i be able to game sometime when there's nothing to do and i want to fuck around

and

yeah it when i get this new computer trust me it's going to be

you

beaches in the chat

white people are the only people

you're part of the nine people that wants to steal my weill

this is probably going to piss me off whatever this is

guilt free cate

was boish

do

that

and

i'm the cook wh you are smashing up your cities and burning your business is and getting beaten up by police

this is a fucking bot

what are you talking about

wow i can't tell the only reason you have that beard is to high your nonexistent chin

there's a video with me with no beard on this channel you fuck and dumb fuck

what a pussy

i have a nonexistent chin my beard isn't even that thick what are you talking about

i have a chin

can't hear too quiet

to rais

i'm the cun but you're smashing your shiny

you're smashing youhini

i'm so i'mpressed

i'm sure praise gd

could please

stop flucking my girlfriend

turn up this abudio

some of those popular

philosophy channel youtue

they also

okay

don't have anything i don't have anything dude

i don't have any invoice

i mean i don't have any

to

yeah

ok

d j hegel

tryceertopes the only dinosaurs we invented birds reptiles and part of the non dinosaurs that thinks they

steal my personal

through

guan but and and

accepted is in by now

he's going to get triggered by the bid

navy

can you hear now yes i can hear you

parking yeah okay

and i can't hear you anymore

you can't heare me anymore no no i can hear no i can hear no right n okay but is it thing

if i put my headphone in you can't hear me

if that means that you'll get some echo or something

byde

leftist can only protest and achieve nothing in the past one hundred years

that's true in the west

communism already tried and the result was nineteen thirty two

uh okay

why do you deny the genocide and intentional starvation why dod you steal why do you deny this see this shit the c ia made up why do you deny it why do you please accept it stop denying it we of cose sorry so yeah ok so the problem is that

if i put my headsphone h i know i know

but do you have auh feedback right h do you have echo right now

yeah but it's not that bad you know it's tolerablek

maybe we can

we can deal with it for now yeaheh we can deal with

it's better than before you know

four was just white noise

okay first of all do theh congratulations with your uh you know

uh too lung didn't breed the

how do you call this that dialectics introduction

thank you appreciate it was sav so tough i mean of course it's a huge topic it's a huge topic

h did just see my comment

on that atter um

you know when i said that for me man diabetics comes up

i think first of all yye the eastern versus the bestern marxist interpretation of directics itself

yeah

yes

so this is a thing you know

i know you don't really like ja p sut

uh and for good reasons but i think he had a good uh criticisms

of the so called eastern marxist or

what he would call

and ganzia marxist view of dialaectics that being that

okay let let let's let's hear uh o out okay so

sub says that you know that angles tried to apply diactics to materialality itself

and and the starts uh criticism of angers is that you know

uh these uh specific dialectical rules

do not actually apply to physics to chemist chemistry and so on

yeah

this is the so called the western conti dialectic goal begins with lupox aion yeah

yeah yeah

that's that's another yeah yeah

but here's the thing uh

here's a thing

you know

for the western marxists

uh this whole

uh how should i call it

framework

of marxism is the

leas

exspected

to

uh social phenomenal ya ya ya ya

it's contient w yence inusationalism

maybe maybe but it's it's what ihul call your point of view

but he is a thing

that

the eastern marshes so so called eastern marhes

there to project

dialectics on to nature itself you know i think this all this is the two

but you know i sogree as you

ok but let's for a second acceptes dualism ok

and you

sart says that that act these is only for social phenomona fat phenomenon and the startss that these so kind of gezia marxist you know the eastern marxists

project this whole dynatics onto nature itself

so we have this

and this

but there's a thing dude

if i accept

sarts definition which is to say that only social phenomenon can be dialecticized

yeah

and

the eastern marsis say that this whole then i thical process can be applied to nature allegly

i would think that this guy has a point

because they

i mean i don't not cle and i did not say that you know human being is a part of nature

but

the westn side

basically implies that not so very much

m

well i want to give you a brief rundown

what i think about this

to me

you know the distinction drawn between marx and angles is unjustified it says from a misreading of marks the way i go resolve this false contradiction

between nature

and the transcendental screen that mediates our relationship to nature that's called sociality

which actually doesn't derive from marks at all it derives from the neocontians of the early twentieth century

that were actually the ideological outgrowth of western social democracy the neo conscience

lucox was actually very much a western social democrat

reacting to bolshevism that's why we're hidi garians infrared the view for us is that idgger and other german conservative intellectuals inadvertently

were giving expression to what was going on with bolshevism

but were too stupid to see that it was bollssm they opted for the fake version which was nazism but that's another story but to me i

the first thing i would want to say is that there is dialectics is against one sidedness but if but there' is a reason why dialectics is either materialist or its idealist likewise we can only be in a sense eastern marxist or we can be western marxist the western marxist will say that reflexively eastern

are superimposing a predefined logic onto nature metaphysical right yeah maybe contradental that metaphysical enthusiasm

but the eastern marxist would say

you're putting words in our mouth

we did no such thing

we merely related

two

objectivity material objectivity

as our objects

this is the source out of which we derive the very necessity

of dialectic thinking

rather than superimpose a preexisting logic upon nature

we replenish our idieology and our

views of the dialectic based on a deeper sublime necessity and i'm going to clarify what that means that results from possessing some kind of sense of the objectve in nature why do i mention sublimity though because another point of distinction between the east and the west is that the east is known for something called

oriental fanaticism which is a special relationship to sublimity

that the west does not have the east relates to the sophiological if you're not familiar with vladimir sol called whatever his name is sophiology the russian guy it's related to the absolute the metaphysical absolute in the object not as a predefined logos but as the more feminine unspeakable un

aathomable

sublime to me the east means materialism in that sense the east means materialism the west to me means idealism the reason i side with the east is not because they think east will destroy the west actually maybe the lesson of mutually assured destruction is that it's not possible for one to destroy the other we're stuck with the contradiction but to me

the east is the source for this contradiction to be replenished the new to be replenished the new and set on new terms just as lenin's thought that the democratic was in the countryside

a could set the class struggle the contradiction of the class struggle on new terms we must always be oriented toward the material

in order for form the ideal and perhaps also the west to be set on new terms

i think that's the wager of materialism before i let you speak need think you so much i was going to ask you please time the fucking idiot out in the chat holy

is it sage again i think it might be sage sages like schizophrenia gives a million different accounts

and he like he larves as a right winger and he larve s ays

yeah time that guy out put him in my little beitch box

filthy how does it feel to be put in time out like a little time out little bits

sorry this is like a ul garity unworthy of a depth is goyh it's ns it's necessary it's up sos necessary

but tak mister thing uh ask

i think the point i missed in your intro to directics

discoursed

is the following

i brought up this example for a very specific reason as i said

theres this so called uh wester marxist point of view theres the so called easter marxist point of view

okay

we can uh

analyse them from

you know their objective perspectives

but here's a thing

for them

the bax the arcist

the easter com maases

go too far

in the sense that they dialecticize uncritically

nature itself

but

from the point of view of eastern marxists

the western marsists don't go far enough

because they faile to realize that the human being

is a national being

so you know

it there is moment

but i think there's this overarching

then this overarg changer

a dialectical approach but there's inside the dialectic

you know there's the overarching

h hager what call it i don't know what you know the

becoming of being becoming of thought whatever

but inside that dialectic

there are subjective positions

that

mutually

eutually

h

misunderstand each other

but i think

for

the dialectic

the masus dialect

hes dialectic as well but for both these dialects

there's always a one and established form

and there's always something

and if you reach egia you understand what i mean and you understand what i mean

there's always something which is only defined

because it is not

it only stands for the further qualification of the form itself

meaning you cannot treat them as two discrete forms that are equals and that we must arrive at a golden mean in between them

one of those stands for the future developments itself another is a crystallized temporary form

given to it that makes sense so to me though this this thing about dialartization of nature

it's not so much that the east in my perspective

does this ya

in my perspective

they view the object

the material object itself

as something

already

latent with a contradiction

it's not that they impose contradictions on reality

they already recognize the one

the object

the material object as itself in regards to our human finitude

contradictory

that's why in the east okay you can sorry but at this at this point at this point sorry at this point i have to be the uh defense lawyer or aso western marxism

because

from their point of view therey they are charging eastern marxists

for being too ready

to directicize nature you know i know the the point is that in

just just to make it clear so from thevest marxis the point of

you

yeah

uh dieticis is uh

one hundred percent uh

proper insight

uh you know human societies

but they say that maybe maybe

dialalectics

can be

used or applied to nature as such

but there are breaking points between you know

uh social

uh biological

and physical and so on but this you know that this dis thing again i don't know the lawy anyway im not notarsing against you in but

yeah the argument itself yeah

do you know that this distinction between

the

radically alien nature

and the human subjectivity

is proper

to i don't want to mention angle because it's good it's paranoid at this point

but it is something

proper to classical madernity initiates this distinction

classical ajoerney

the east's response to classical modernity has always been to say that rather than possit nature purely in as marx actually would put it as nature wholly estranged from man nature must be perceived as the sight within which this contradiction is reconciled which means

that would basically the i'll try to give you my perspective on what the western marxists are think and some of their errors the first er i think they make is that they superimpose upon easterners every flexivity that's not there they say that the easterners are reflexively beginning as idealis and then superimposing their idealism

upon material reality

whereas is good conscience they say no

there is an other

the thing in itself if you will the blind nature the metaphysical metaphysically a strange nature and we must respect that or else we're going to pollute the purity of science modern science and so so on so they say easterners should not you did they basically underestimate easterners and they t they think that the easterners are unprepared for the

shocking revelation that nature there's something fundamentally a stranged about nature from our human society and human subjectivity but the problem in my perspective is this they make two assumptions

one that in the east there is a fortress human society a comfort space

and two

that the otherness of nature is somehow foreign and impossible and shocking to eastern societies when in fact

it's precisely something they're so used to you don't even have to mention it it's a given that

out there is different theres something gve being given to us that is different from our experect nature somehow humiliates us the other the object but the whole east is built upon this fact the east itself is defined by some type of recognition and assimilation and conformity to this this is the sublime object of the east

they don't even have a fortress that is called the transcendental human social relations of society that can be divorced from this the whole thing is based on this radical encounter with

the sublime object this is why this is why there's western racism more or less because the east is associated with monsters hoards from the

yeahk ok so still keeping on me this

uh you know theme of me being the lawyer of the wester marxists if i may

you know

you yourself

as a leconian

of some sort

you know ty well

that didn't say

quanitative

difference

emerging from the fact that the human infant

it starts to learn or becomes

mm

human subject

that is

a human subject that uh

masters or is or is in the process of mastering a language as such

you i mean as a lecanian you have to accept this fact that uh

there's this and pmll being which is the part of the homosapis you know our rates

and after the point that little idiotic being starts to get some kind of point that oh my god this is a language which in i'm included

and there's another and so on

and the western marxists

stress this point of view that there's a qualitative

shift

from the biological you homosapi s infant

to the speaking being infant

but

i you're right you're right but i think

even from a laconian

spective what i would say is that

this ship

should radically

shame

what it is we thought

was the at original biological

human

we should reinscribe

like this is how i think

the dialectician escapes anglo saxon temporal

ok ok

you're become a time traveler

rather than

say

first you have the human who is a biological animal

and then

there's a radical rupture

in which you enter the symbolic order so on is

we must say instead

this rupture proves to us something about the essential nature about the original animal

solf

don't like'

almost there almost that it proves a fucking point about ontology itselfy you know

be ajck in here that there's something there's a gap in precisely precisely

that's why s reality itself yet that's why susu always makes the point

of remembering that marx quote

we learn the anatomy of an ape

through

yeah

and i think this is the material was

di ya but from this uh she sharking your point of view

if i may uh reframe my lawyer defense of the soperbastn marxist it will be this that the so called eastern marxists uh

basically just

step

over

uh this gap of onthology they say that you know human is just another animal

there we go it's solt

but for divestor marxist it's a bit more complicated and by the way i have a be mean let's just make this clear that byvester marxist i don't mean anglos you know i i know i beeve you mean you know everything sa of course

what i would say is that

this problem stems from the fact

that easterners do not do well

in the shop

or in the

the i don't want to say you not urn you said notur they do not dwell in being impressed or shocked

or

it's superflu the oft upture yet for them it's superfluous it's a given that they're not exactly

and for them this is why the east represents

this precise rupture in its actual material development

whereas the west tries to pin down the essence of what it is

by some kind of reflexive informal means

and you can even argue this is true before

majority i mean what was the western scholasticism if not this ok ok yeah i get your point i get you point

but you know

i mean

inside your mind has

there must be

some kind of you know

antagonism

because as a

suppose lekinia youus see

that there's a rupture

when a human being becomes a speaking being a subject

proper you

but

my and it's lucky and you must acknowledge the fact that there's a qualtitative difference it this is the dialectic we're talking

all right

all right but we're also talking about the different dialectic which is being you know the

western and eastern maarxists no no i know i know and i know the i'm speaking about the rupture you're talking

my point is that

the eastern

yes

recognize this dialect

as the very object

of

veneration and

worship and devotion

basically the object

material object itself and

furthermore

but there it's the perspective of ultimately of wisdom

the easterners perspective says

initially we experience

the shok

inerruption this is where i kind of break was usic

not kind of

really blak pictre

uh

there is a kind of shock or an interrupt

but it's only because we are now delivered to a deeper more fundamental sense

positive

material of

this shark

disrupture

is proper to the sublime object

self whereas what would what would es should say

he would almost say the same thing

but jesjak would instead say

that the rupture

the shock is itself the only real thing

the object is only this kind of abstraction of this rupture the shot

for the easterner there is a positive material object not empirical

not substantial

positive material object

which reconciles

the whole shock which is not in it's we're talking about the same shock the infant entering the symbolic order

and the pre modern subject entering moderny

is exactly the same thing we're

my

ok hans

so reight okay what

what you just said i are so let me be phrase my you know lawyer phase you what you just said

so for the wester marxis they would say that

you just said

in defense of eastern marxism that they have the so called object

and for them it's a popable you know touchaball

something a possible material reality

and you know the eastern massies but sorry the western massiest would say that

this is exactly the reason why we had the gulag

this is exactly the reason i hed this startingism and so on and these excesses

of course of course i don't disagree

both stalinism gulag

the taliban

i wouldn't say i sus i blame on the english

but islamic iranian revolution mao was excesses

all these excesses yes

but to me

these excesses represent the open and honest developments of material reality in its actuality

the west pretends to be civilized

but on the ridge in the border of the west

we find the same excess

so so come me so can we agrey on this point basically that the

as you said on your previous dream that

fuking reality is brutal

it's disgusting pcise but it is what it is

precisely yes

so this gives a point to easter marxists versusy basically yes i mean

this is actual reality in its

nyd developed

itut hiding behind

the safe space

ok we are so only given to the real and concrete

brutality

contradiction of the world

without finding refuge

h would lennin for example would call the hipocritical reff

o

social chauvinists

who speak of the civilized west

well at the same time

so

here we are

a

you just had a i don't know twenty minutes discussion i don't know previously

about sages idiotic thread

about you know the world is a gulag but we agree

basically if the word is not a good but it's a really fucking ugly place you know you know why i reject that post so much the world is a good g because to me

the thing that defines gulaug is not that it was able to control

people

but that when you look out from the perspective outside of the gulad you see a type of chaos

to me sages fantasy of the world as a gulag

is a quintessential western fantasy of attempting to impose exactly a form upon that

second second

exactly

and and you know another thing another thing

for i think that for seeg this gulab

fantasy of he sorr he's in the chat right now and he's you know you know

hey mods hey fellow months just give him a time out or whatever you know

talking with this media

no i mean seriously

has i don't know if you if you know this but the

sage

or openly sad with his fucking hash tags or whatever on left the boll that he was insane

i mean he openly says he' is insane do what are we doing here right now why are we responding to him nowch he says he's insane ok do that

you know maybe need some la com maybe you need some psychiatrist p psychologist p psychoanalyst but don't fuck in

spam this fucking thread

don't you have anything better to do you foll you doesn't you he doesn't

but it's this is your point isn't it fascinating though that

why are people attracted

to success in this way and have this impulse

just destroyed

because

they are people who enjoy failure

and they wanted m

they it's like misery love's come

you know they want

drag

it's like but why us why target us what is our crime it infrared what's our crime

our crime is

ing success do you want to do you want my take honestyy

it' so fuck in autistic do

he is he's the

that

too long didn't read version of has

hverses

a sage here it comes

sag said

strikes are direct action

has proved that you know anything that is neediated like union strikes

are by definition lo them definition are not heck

and from that point on this fucking little goblin this fucking little golum goum goum

mind blown and he tries to stay face and this is all this is all his fucking h dear

you know i'm not to address sage but more on this thing of direct action

you want know america with how sickening the context

direct action is though

you know you

for every good communist understands the real struggle is at the site

well

of laos

what

the right it's a russian word for power

means

kind of th

executive

a cold

primordial

sight of real power

the dictatorship the class dictatorsi

right

you know what a marxis this real power would you know stem from productivity

you know yeah butm but it's is stranged and singularly manifested in some type of in the soviet union for example

this is how they referred

power don the e of cat river

we must seize the

largely wrote an article about

months

i

this is the site at which

ah

the class struggle reaches its most advanced

level right

in america

in america

because leftist completely failed bernie sanders and he failed himself

course

instead of going and corbin in the uk

seort of going back to the drawing board and asking what the fuck did we do wrong

i see a bunch of youus and now it's time for direct action run in the street and this is the discuss it in context it's a cop out

from the objective side of struggle

from an objective going back to the books

and think about

why did we fok this up so bad

you know he's

why is it

that we were unable to continue

and develop the objective contradictions

of the american politics what did we do wrong instead of doing this they say

this individualistic stupidity

th

let's directly go and do things individually

well this is a cop up this is laziness you can't just directly go and do it

you know that's that's one of the contexts of direct

you know

has this is one of the saddest ispects i don't think you're familiar with

but as a hungar indian from

a so called exx socialist country

this is the fucking view from my point uh

don't

are so cod

leftists here

are in a leg

i do familiar with this definition you know so the's happening here

it happens and the leg means that

after the

after a time t's adopt it yeh you here'sing

yeah

this fucking idiot

leftists leftists in my country are basically

in a five to ten year leg

between anglos basic yeah yeah so right now

they start making parties in my country

cause

democratic socialist o yes yes dude yes so after after after fucking burnie failed

twice

after fucking corbin failed after fucking series a failed in a greece dud

they are just now starting to make their own democratic socialist parties

they're like in a time they're in a different deion ok here's some optimism

optimism

ready

yeah you want to know it's also sign of proglem

because

it seems like they're behind

the hunk hungaryan people are behind

but it's just because they're s the're

their speed running

that makes sense

yeah because the internet speeds it up yeahh it's true

they're going to speed run it and then

soon maybe a year or two they're going to be ahead of the west

hopefully let's be up there ah but sorty it's also a politic uh class political element to this because you know

those people who start this fucking uh democratic socialist parties who try to copypaste corbin and so on

they are these

eternally online

fucking you know

b m c people you know it's like it's like you know so they have the fucking

yeah it's interesting because it's like

the internet's an american invention and when we're on the internet unless we have china's great firewall which particular reparticularizes the internet

and that's the tendency we're in

now take not

but

up till now yes up till now the internet

is the ultimate america everyone who's on the internet is an america

way right at least

in the outside of china but

here's the thing is that

you know there's that you know those means

of the political compass that show the different walljacks in different boxes that are really big ones the really big political compass compasses

that show all the wojacks like from left to right and

you know i'm talking about

course

yeah

i think these are the

these represent

the quintessential american perspective

and the reason is because

the internet has allowed us to abstract ourselves

from our country i'm speaking i'm an american so i'm not included

but if we're outside of america

the internet abstracts us

from our local countries

and allows us to see ourselves from an alien

the universal perspective

these olitical compass means to me are the quintessential form of that

and to me this represents actually

ah

the next stage

ushered in by china is that we're going to rise from the abstract

back to the concrete

ok ok that's was too fast for me

ya

how does the checkine ah

gets because theause is china has passed through

the american majornity

in the form of

twentieth century state socialism

then it has the internet

but china's internet for example has the great firewalls

so it's particularized internet

china does not see internet communication as

virtual abstract in the void in

you send it off into the void and it's addressed to whomever it concerns

china says no fuck you were going to trace you to the exact material conditions

of your existence

what's your ip what's your computer what's your server what's the power plant

partnts

that's energized

they've nailed down the infrastructure of the internet and kind of

you know what i mean like

they arrive from the abstract back to the concrete

and i know you're this infrastructure

i know you're not the kind of guy but i still have to ask did you hear the latest chapelon house episode

no no i dide

okyh of course not okay n anyway i i clipped

the version that i think is important in the

theu left

people p r c thread you know people's republicus chinad

uh and you know these fucking anglos these fucking reditors that are ch apples rapples and idiots

they themselves said

you know

they contrasted

what the wesn media said about china

and their so called coplet nineteen response brazls

chinnel's you know big data and so on

infrastructure and their um

u copit the response

and even this fucking red lep

chapeld prouss ready tours said that ok

so here's the picture on the one hand

there's china

and in bejing you know twenty something twenty three million people living there and zero

fucking covid casees is

meanwhile they are using big data and so on

in a centralized manner

on the other hand we have

fucking new york or whatever

i don't know how many million people

and we have you know

ten thousand people dying every year every every day

so what the fop

meanwhile in the so called free vest

the pick that up

functions the big data functions

but not only not in the same ay as in china in china big data in a sense serves

yah

making sure that cobe doesn't spread

in the best

big diita spreads for what u you know

tracking my buying results

tracking my girlfriend

you know this is the

the same technology on both sides

and the differences between results

okay okay hans

you know one one more fucking thing because uh

because i know you love the debate and so on

so you know on on your latest video i i uh

i made the comments can you can you show it on your screen maybe

oh yeah yeah sorry i briefly forgot but i remember wh you talked

which one was it on was on the

give me a second more i

it's on the video called you can stop the inevitable o

sure

and it starts me it's likelly i my pe i sorry for not yh

so i don't know who's this uh

o t n o t guy is

the enalty

oh i didn't yeah i didn't see that one

okay but anyway

i think that uh this uh o t n oti guy is somewhat um

how should i call it

and i rest of license

best of es is your your basic points

let me let me read it just to see if i can give my pching

revolution is a multi cit

i agree with that insurrection it might us

yes i agree with that

there is no after the revolution

you think that's a

roses and

i kind of agree with that

you have to abandon your utopian

there thingy do for that the revolution is realis

i kind of agree with him ya i just i i think you g i give it my approval ya

okay so here's my point

i basically kind of

agree with those points

but you know the devil is in the ou ort deenenationvi that wasn in the detailsight

its bactly exactly exactly

so you know

that

just just for the second you know uh

are we going to

for feet

uh this term revolution

are we going to what

are you going to say that evolution this term is out of the indoor or something i mean come on

i mean the mot

i no no i see where you're coming from i think

ya

i think um

i think we shouldn't abandon it but we should just be more careful about

how we use

and not use you haven't used to abused it but

i see a lot of leftists always talking about the revolution and

the revolution is the revolution that

i' get your point

when you say that you know when these lefter massist think about the revolution they think about salvation

if

i'm not on that train

you know what train i'm on

has and you said in your last them that you fucking hate this movie called ds

yeah yeah i hate it

ok so this is the to lg didn't watch version of friends

that is about

a fucking romantic idiot bear or something fucking anarchists going to russia

uh in nineteen seventeen

and they were enthusiastic

and wen they saw how brutal

how realistic

the fucking revolution was they said

ok

s i go home now is this the went for the party

and may

they left after the cleanup yeah

so from my perspective

i don't think that we should abandon the term revolution but

by revolution we shouldn't think that it's kind of salvation or whatever no the revolution is at the point when the real verk starts

revolution is at the point

then we have to fuck in dirty are fucking hands

revolution is the point where nothing will be beautiful devolution is the point thaty be fucking

barbaric

towards our enemies because we have to be

know that is the remtion for me

of course this convers to mind to me also french rel

right i mean also we should also have another sense of revolution

is also a

i don't want to

provoke more arguments but any doing angelsian

revolution in nature itself for example

to me the geological

we should have a poetics a revolution

even in the

violence

geological and cosmological

changes that happen in nature

itself

i think this is a nice poetic s

revolt

like

revolution in the forces of production

something that's happening in reality

s

ah only we subjectively can be worthy of that

inar

we can only be devoted to ok one more thing

force

okay one more thing

okye

i uh

one hundred percent of ball was

this view

that seeing anything

so called positive

y

how should i say predictive

or you know

things about what happens after the revolution is utopia

i mean let's be fair here

even marks and angles themselves

in the communist manifesto in the second chapter

have a tem point program

you're empy program here

you know it's outdated and so but they basically propose

they say that you know for every developed country we say that one two three four five whatever

this should be generally done

i mean i think it's so

yeh

it's interesting you

when you read that

ten planks in the manifest

it's almost like

marx and angeles are saying

we must do these things to catch up

some

but the something doesn't exist yet isn you get that impression that they're saying basically ok

we need to do these just to catch up

what are we catching up

can be open can be open that ten points on

okay so it's u corporate s manifesto second chapter

a

ofh for the museum

sorry

communists and infestal

s

marxist that or will show up

this being sucks

okay

two and then it's chapter two ok here we go

oh yah

hould up

sage is so cute dude he's like he's our smeagle

is ore doalking

he said you know

it's so crazy how filthy he made a sack popent called filthy insurrectionist

because he was he was too scared to be racist

as sage

so he may fil the insurrection is the talk

i gut about the brown skin

m

that's funny

okay sorry uh

let's continue

do you have it opened yet

ya it's open it's open

spy s faestal second chapter yeah it's a its omt the end plinks te plinks right now

maybe you read it out and they comment so it they say

nevertheless in most advanced

countries the follow we pretty generally applicabal

abolition of property and land and application of all rents of land to public purpose

heavy progressive or graduated income tax

abolition of all rights of inheritance

confiscation of the property all emigrants and rebels

centralization of credit in the hands of the state by mean

of a national bank with

state capital and an exclusive monopoly

centralization of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the state

extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the state

the bringing into cultivation of wasteland and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with the common plan

equal liability of all to work thousand of industrial armies especially forragcal

combination of agriculture with manufacturing interest industries

gradual abolition of all distinction between town and country by a more equitable distribution of poplace over the country

free education for all children in public schools abolition of children's factory labor in the present form

combination of education with industrial production

that's it

cancel and and one yes yes yes

okay

so

let me my my first first fucking thing that comes to mind

point eight

mmhm

equal

lay lay up ho this si all to work liability

yeah

of waterwork

and this is a thing

from our so called enarchist critics you know many moreeran anarchists look at the so called a primitive communism like for example david greer who just died thank for god

fock fok you hem him or not to show you with thehm but

isn't his idea about that kind of interesting

you don't like it

ok so there's the labor theory value and gber tried to invent a new anthropologistic anthropologistic theory of notal but

i kind of e from a lekanian perspective this idea of

money is emerging from and i owe you one

know i kind of think maybe something can be done

but

i see how in conflict

prone and i just want

okay so contin so to continue on this point yeah eight plus e liabi liability

of all to bed

now i'm

i'm not an english native speaker but when i double click on liability

it says for me as the definition just a second

obligated it's just

responsibility for something oh my god

oh my god

these fucky marxists are saying that people should have

responsibilities

that nott

and you know for these fucking anarcho bushy people

uh they triy to copy paste

fucking primitive communies societies

ben

you know everything works

spontaneously you know gan that he goes to hunt grandmamma goes to fucking get the and had to get

that's all patriarchal

depression you just mentioned grandmamma we don't have the ditinctions but we fuck the grandma we fuck

it's all incest there's no what are you talking about the patriarch

yeah yeah so this is the twenty first century communist program

f grandma

here gramdpa

instcest is revolutionary go on twitters will tell you that

but to be serious for the moment

so you se has but i'm saying that you know communism and marxist thought

can ih be uh you know

the separated

from some kind of positivistic thinking not in the fielsopical sense but in the sense that

we have to have some kind of standard some kind of pro positive positive proposals let me try what you after the evolution try to reword it

think what i'm

actin to try

i think i see you're trying

let me try to see

we must have

we must

understand we must get some kind of sense

of what is that stake

politically

in terms of the

not creation of a new society per se

but in the basic way in which

the contradictions in the forces of production can be related to

politically

by means of policies and so on

you must have a basic sense

of that

a hunch suspicion some kind of sense of

one thing

the bummer think they would add

we've rered this c ten point program

y this is a thing

let's say you were a party focking communist party and you have such a program

the crucial thing about this is that this tempoate problem gives you a back forards view of what is wrong

with your current society yeah precisely precisely

precise like if we were season power it would be as easy as doing this and we can

i see where you're coming from

you know here's the only thing i want to say

the two things i want to say the first thing is that

one way infrared

tries to

fill this hole i know it's not an

we say we want to learn from china

because

when they wrote this

they were talking about catching up with some

that didn't exist of cose

with the objective forces of product

i think the word china

denlegdes

the third ord

what is a denlegation

the i think understan what you ch saying know it es it represents this oubjective revolution in the forces of production china

so when i say we must learn from china

this is what i mean china represents this thing we must catch up

i know it's not enough

but here is the most fatal thing i want to avoid

above all i'm

completely

completely against

and want to avoid

i don't want to create a program and then

wave it around as my little red book and scream at people and say listen this is our program just lit follow us and we can do this yah this is all you have to do is follow us we can just do this

you like that's what i'm trying to avoid

i agree with you i basically agree with your point

but i think it's only meaningful if we

are humble about

our subjective position of enunciation

let's not hold society to the measure of

accepting our ten planks

and and just say everyone stupid because no one's accepting that ten planks

you know if you would just listen to me this is a path i don't want to

i see many leftis

this is where i think we would have a kind of onehd

con

but you know you sd we're if were more modest

and we just want to

have a basic sense of what you were talking aout

basic sense of

what

how can we relate

politically to what can be done our conditions of

all this kind of stuff

completely agree with

we agree

but i also would add that

we also must bear in mind that

when you seize power

we have a lot of freedom

do many

and that's the most

important thing is the struggle

mean because if you could seize power you can do all sorts of

you know

but i basically agree with you need some sense

you need something to clarify

but

i just think we cannot

have the er of the little red book

the fanaticism over

andanther thing i don't want to fall into the air of doing is

making this our true en goal and holding all

reality

political phenomena under the standard of this specific

so i think that's what i would absolutely

i would also say that you know

i'm not an idiot so i know that uh

using this term this bom beastic term because by its very nature it's bom bestic

this term revolution

should be contextualised should be used in different uh

you

how do you ca this in english i'm so sorry

so in different uh places you should use it in different places you should bet

is an example

uh cann moubing

you know the guy

here

how many times did he say revolution

i think like you can count it on your o hands maybe five times

and this guy is employed by artie dot com so you know

ok

maybe i if you were a streaming channel like yours is

like infrad is maybe you shouldn't bomb this fucking term every fucking now and then

maybe if you try to

educate the fucking masses me bya your stream about basic realities

basic way to understand reality and so on

i completely understand it

but do it

here's a content example if i may

could you please open on youtube

uh this recent uh p s r video called uh

not a riot

an uprising

it's a p s r video

ok before i think what is

if you like it or you don't like

but what do i like

do you like it or you do not like

i absolutely fucking adot it i think it's the

like the most evolutionary thing i've seen from america

um from ten to years now

wow

so nothing i and pris from

liberation s

pce

on

i'm uh plyning it right now

okay

hepaking more than one

howny thousand

wow

yeah

that

but

so i don't want to interrupt it but just one one thing is

don't you think

this was kind of a miss

representational

protests and stuff like

they turned out to just be a kind of carnival

no

ok

from my point of view

yeah i'm going to be comtly honest and the plad is fact checked

what i'm willing to say is

you

andy

okay

court

my basic point is do that the

let's look at how

uh b

you know these froth youngman beme to be

is starting underfucking obama

and in fa gosson

they had something malrg

like um

fucky dog broadcast and you try to burn everything

pht of any

justified reasons

that was more like a spont spontaneous thing right that was like people from the community expressing

yes

but it' starting to grow and then that point

you can google in this month

yeah you're right you're right you're right i know you're going to say what happens

not the

yeah yeah yeah yeah

ok

no you're right you're right you're right what happened is no no no no you're right

at the democratic party

and a bunch of activists

from in universities

they took over the whole fucking thing

they saw there was an organic

uprising in ferguson

and then opportunistically they made themselves the figurehead of that even though they had no organic

connection to the

black community people

at all

and black lives matter the phrase black lives matter

would eventually become a democratic party brand

yeah a brand for the democratic party that's all it is

and i know black nationalists

who view would

black nation many black nationals viw

real black let nationals not the kind of

wok academic whatever but real ones who are

we have militias and stuff

you know like

so what you're saying isn't

it's nothing bad about it all

is it because

the you cannot contain

this is the most beautiful thing about it

they cannot farking contain

these fucking sho foundations

hes ing for foundations they cannot ain however they try

the caus de farking black anger

in america

he

yeah

but they're trying

they're trying really hard to you're right you're right

hundred

ok single white

the reason why i brought up this video because

this guy from the b s l

and basically gives the uniful speech

that says you know fath this af on is ched

we are for revolution

so when i said that this evolution talk is all about content

this is what i mean

okay

on the one hand

i differently understand my in mobing son

yeah

on the other hand

bang the pocket you know

more than one hundred thousand people had of fe you

yeh

you know

a

you know

a

what you know one thing just to kind of

keep the dialectu

the thing with the revolutions st is almost like everyone

agrees about a revolu

it's just what does that mean you know everyone's always talking about a

this is the right like it's just almost like we're in era in america we're after the sixties

we all want the revolution apple wants

the beatles one

everyone's talking about it but what does it actually mean

knowo

supposedly sam

fate in all these pes were an evolution by the way

by the way man the revolution

the whole time

is here us having fun

and getting out on the street

and that's the revolution man

it's all right you know like

it all ends with this kind of

bad fake eastern wisdom the ones esic always talks

that

the whole time the revolution you were looking for

was right here man on the street

would you agree with this point of view that

time

morning

thes point to the few aut the devolition is the following

the resolution

is always at the horizon

and my eyes are always on the erise

i do not speak

so he's in the mot that ever

because it's

my basic

eight

i do not

best standizes this fuckingtterm revolution

it know being my this solve my problems i mean this is the hard

struckle

that i feel sometim

maybe

lead us to do that point

and met that for us

anxio

the only thing i would add to that

out add

a kind of evil uh

satanist

you go to your you

solar soul in victors

view

the sun behind the horizon i would also say you look behind the horizon

and then you can see

that behind the horizon there's a cliff

the thing behind the horizon goes underground

and it's moving the earth below your feet

and it's moving the earth below your feet

thing that's behind the horizon

and the revolution

is a violent process

in which the ground you stand on

very ground you stand on will trust me

tremble yeah

destroyed

even if i can never shrin

the song for theion please

some of them will tremble

and some of them you'll find those

they'll be the first who triy some kill lenin who tried to kill little an anarchist

yeah how how's that how that you know that guy you called out uh not so long ago that idiot socialist who has this fucking fedora eomic

nathan robins yeah

oa

it would be the first to fucking you know abandon the fon always listen because in we talked about before in one of our videos

you know in china

who are the biggest collaborators with japan

in the thirties

ex communist party members

because they saw that mao was going to the countryside and they were urban

intellectuals and this humiliated them it offended them

so they sided with the japanese occupier

listen

the first traiters the first betrayers they're all leftists look

left who tried to kill and redly who tried to kill infrared iness in its cradle people from lefty poole even people from fortune came

and some of them

yes they they kind of lagt

the first people that will try to spit on you will try to drag you down will try to destroy you

if you try to get anywhere it's always going to be other leftists the're always going to be your number one number one andenemy

and that's we how we're living ample urmy

how pathetic are we do

but it's it's almost in it's almost like religion like

like it's o i don't wan the anti semitic

but

it's almost like when jesus came

and his own people were the first ones

to attack him

because he

with he was

i'm

where i can already see the lefty pol people saeing has thinks he's like jesus

ok let me look we're roll that back ll the back we it's not what i mean

not what i mean not what i mean

all that back all that back

meams ams incoming meams incoming ohm

all i me say is

what i'm trying to say is that

leftist

take pleasure in their failure

and

they learn to adjust to it and enjoy

and whenever you try to be successful

the people in your own group

are going to be the ones

try to drag you down

that's why to me i always say something

we can't focus on other leftists

we must focus on the people

keep our eye on the ball

maybe i have a better chance with fortune than i have with a lot of people on left

i think that is the case despite that

most of left people i think loves us

that minority that hates us i think i have an easier time with fortune and these aders these lefti has

and the simple reason is because

the real test of whether we're going to be successful or not

isn't going to be whether we please our own echo chamber

we must compete ruthlessly

the left must compete ruthlessly to win the masses

win the people

then whoever wins the people will be the real ones you know it's like it's almost like

imagine if the bolsheviks

said oh forget about the masses

we should just focus on

winning the economists

and the ments of it

all these opportunities no they said no

it's the democratic dictatorship of the workers and peasants

this is the people the bolseviks must win

whoever wins

whens

very game

if infrared becomes successful

fair game

if

the if sage becomes successful

in winning

fair game i'll give it to him i'll learn from sage if hes success

he can start his own stream

and see how successful he's going to be i'm not going to drag you down

see i'm one of those people where i say

if you're successful even if i hate you i disagree with you and you're a leftist

i will never try to kill you inhen your cradle

i will only come after you after you've already been established

very

nw i only critique people who've reached their limits and will not come to terms with the fact

that you're failing

it's your own fault you're not growing big

only when we reach our limit

and we don't grow bigger and we're not more successful

and we start blaming the world

that's when i'm going to come after you when you're growing

and you're being successful i'm not going to come after you kill you in your cradle try to kill you in your cradle

i'm going to say

even if i disagree with it

let me see what's going to happen maybe something interesting will happen

what can i learn from them

you know that's my mentality

m sotin h okay uh two things has

uh the first thing is basically bus shit post h how do you call this shit posting

but since stage is still on topic

do you know for do you know do you know for the fact that uh

what is this so called labor organizeding sage does cparently

no i don't i know nothing about m okay let me enlighten you because h sh said this in several threads

siege has a tenant

union

the

so that is is basically that

he knocks on the door

on the second door and the third door

to his fellow you know tenants and they stay ok fuck the landlord

we won't pay our rents for a month

or so

and that is his tucking union dudes

so i mean forgres the fall maybe i should be a

i mean okay so first of all okay good for you because you beeve they wk in uh

adamspace

ricardo level of consciousness which says that

and david bourgeis economists by the way but you reach that consciousness that says that farcking landlords are

panicides upon the one not just that

but it's basic self interest

right

yeh of course not going to you know

good for you basically yh but here's the thing here's the thing

for marxists unions meant a different thing you know yeah because for us fucking marxists means that

we

fucking

grab the neck of capital and

fucking strangerly

at the point of

production

and the point of product seeins eat what they're going to say is they're going to say we are doing this

this because thk this is no they're goy they're going to say they're going to say

we're doing this

no matter how small and no matter how local we're doing our part

because for example they're going to say

re's going to be like a toy shop

and they're going to say

we stop the toy shop from operating so ho how small and marginal

we did stop production that's really how they think they individualized yes

and they feel like they reproduce that at the individual level and they did their charity

and they did their work

es for them

they will say for themselves you know thisa has this wonderful speech about you know

at one point

we rebelled again capital and after twenty years we cae be became you know p the bourgeois whatever became the next the

bill gates and so on

this is the fucking place ofre sagest

he thinks that the

companying a tenant

the landlords is some kind of radical resistance

but it's not because it doesn't touch basic

social

ontology by that

i mean the facty marxis point of view that

believe in class struggle

and class struggle is determined by who is working at who is

fucking the paraicide on that very

and

the tenant unions it doesn't work like that i'm so sorry you know what good for them you know always good for them but

shut p

fock p you fucking iio sys you fucking the roll

you know

the thing i want to tell my viewers

if anything

i'm never going to tell my viewers to go out on the street

do the revolution

all this possile

oh go wor i'm never you know i'm not going to tell them to go organize i'm not going to tell you bre

you i want to say to do

if i can help you in any way

i can't give you money

what

why not

do what the actuly bets doing let's make some fucking money how about that

because you need money to eat

before anything

if you want to know more about marxism youeed to support yourself so let's become capitalist is make some fucking money

you know i'm saying

instead of spending time organizing

why don't just make money

if you have money you can do anything

and i'm so sick of this fake you know morality all that's organized thiss organized because at the end of the day they're going to rely on the soros money

right and ok d of the day it's always going to come down to institutional money and some kind of backer who does have money who you're going to rely on

and i know what i'm saying is impossible we're not going to be able to make money we're not

but i'm just saying if i was going to advocate any direct action it would be trying to advice to make some fucking money

somehow you know yeah

okay you know it my direct action for fucking sage and everybody who

even thedares to talk about direct acection is the following

read

fucking marx you fucking india that's the first direct action autstic fucking anglo

but then they're going to says and they're going to say

i'm too poor and i have too much i have to spend too much time working even though they have time to be my chatrom

yeah you play

then i would say

if you want help at an individual level

you have to find we have to you know

i don't know if i can help you but

you gota you know

hustle or so i know i sound like

lift yourself by your bootstraps

but you have a big better chance of getting out of poverty if you have the time to come on the internet stuff

trying to look up ways to make money

on the internet

then you do

doing direct action or organizing if you're going to st speak of things individualistic terms that's the plain reality individualistically

for your own life you have a better chance devoting all your time to trying to make money then you do

having a revolution pan out and work in your lifetime there's a reason why revolutionaries sacrifice their lives for the revolution

they never individualized it and said oh i'm i'm a revolutionary i'm lenin and i'm poor and the revolution's going to allow me to live a better life they completely self sacrificed and devoted themselves

and they didn't even think about themselves the individual didn't exist it was only you know me

fully devoted to the object the revolution

or the proletariat as the class or whatever

so that's what's wrong with me i make yes i go

if i may

connected to what you said

i think this is about uh this general line about uh

fucking you know

uh western

moralism

you touched upon this point from different angles

like you know

a catholic n n know you call it a protestant protestant ethic and so on that's very fair

but in on theres

even outside protestant ethic you know she just mezed respond that uh

yeah

the current day buddhism is more suited

hello

ya ya i i can hear you

ok ok so so that even it's a course western buddhists and so on

that moralism a concrete example

exactly from sage and his lk

they think that

if you are a communist

and you

let's see

on effectively

you are a bastard

all right

so

mom must try to remind them that you know fucking angles

basically on the factory

and facki marxists

on stocks

those different because of

it was different because i

you know they we were perfect

you know so we have to be more per

they were

trying to imagine what they would say

yeah but he it's the thing

after they say these that you know you may not want to beus this as a communist

they say that ok what's the solution you have to collpate that cop that

co open that eyes

your industry

under capitalism

which is

for many reasons i'm not going to go into night now

is absolutely non workable and so on

but this is a basic point about the

moralism and the what he gol called

mm

you know why

that sorry i forgot

exactly but he's a thing has

would you be so kind to read out

for fucking bettergraphs

the fronds and how long they are

if you if you take one and a half minutes ok

in the chat i told you when you were talking about this topic that i don't think that your audience exactly

understands

what the beautiful soulis

and i think there's a text that perfectly captures that

just a second

lincoln in the a

it's cold the

and

the soul of man

under th exactly

and the youunverse i'm going to link it but

i just wanted to have a disclaimer

i hate

the bread tubes

obsession with us who will

oh yeahh of course yeah yeah they don't want the size i agree with you

the thing about the terst

yeah

but please s please read the first four paragraphs what everyone heres sre will see that what this falcking beautiful soul is

the chief advantage that will result from the establishment of socialism

undoubtedly

the fact that socialsm would relieve from us the sorti of necessity of living for others which in the present condition of thing press so hard

on almost everybody

fact scarcely anyone at all skp

now and then in the course of the century

a great man of science like darwin

great poet like keiths

fine critical spirit

like mr rerennan supreme artist like flobber

has been able to isolate himself

keep himself out of reach the clamorous claims of others

to stand under the shelter of the wall

as plato puts it

and sort of realize the perfection of what was in him

to his own in comomparable gain

to the incomparable and lasting gain of the whole world

these however are exceptions the majority of people spoil their lives by an unhealthy and exaggerated altruism

are forced to indeed so to spill them they find themselves surrounded by hideous poverty by hideous ugliness byo starvation it is inevertable they should be so strongly moved by all of this the emotions of man are stirred more quickly than man's intelligence and as i pointed out some time ago in an article on the function of criticism

it is much more easy to have sympathy with suffering

than it is to have sympathy with thought accordingly with admirable though misdirected intentions they very seriously and very sentimentally set themselves to the task of remedying the evils that they see

but their remedies do not cure the disease they merely prolong it indeed their remedies are part of the disease

to try to solve their problem of poverty for instance

by keeping the poor alive

or in the case of very advanced school by amusing the poor

but this is not a solution it is angate aggravation of the difficulty the proper aims to try and reconstruct society on such a basis that poverty will be impossible

and the altruistic virtues have really prevented the carrying out of this aim

just as the worst slave owners were those who were kind to their slaves and so prevented the horror of the system being realized by those who suffered from it

and understood by those who contemplated it

so in the present state of things in england the people who do the most harm are the people who try to do the most good and at last we have had the spectacle of men

who have really studied the problem and know the life educated men who live in the east end coming forward and emploring the community to restrain its altruistic impulses of charity benevolence and the like

they do so on the ground that such charity degrades and demoralizes they are perfectly right charity creates a multitude of sins

that's it that's it

for me

he goes beautiful soul

we summarizing this sentence

it is much more easy to have sympathy with suffering

then it is to have sympathy with

thought

and of story

mmhmm

i have a

question from the chat if you don't mind

gar marks

how do you think the gig economy can be unionized

for examplere how do you unionize drivers because i feel like you're trying to impose order when there is n

in that case

i don't even think were drivers want to be unionized

but how would you do it

for example but i'm open to what would you have to say

no i di' i din't talking to me i sa no no no no just the guy check

because he's saying we're not being fair to unions

and i also mentioned

i don't think the ga economy can be unionized

but i could be wrong

maybe i'm missing

yea i mean honestly there are very basic physical problems with the g academy and you literally cannot

union unioniz them in the classical sense

i mean

for sure i think what you can do with the gig economy is maybe you can establish standards political

right ok on a political level but

creating an economic union

i don't think works in the in the digital age

comes

seventh

online if even possible that's interesting so you can somehow do it online but how were should be an open source i agree with that especially times ok dud

i think uh this is our time no

ma maybe our discussion is coming to an end now

yeah i think so too our stream has been going on for a long time and

okay do i fuck in lave okay come back

you towo man g always a pleasure

always a pleasure to have conjit on the stream

always an interesting conversation always an interesting dialectic and i love

all right man see later

i wasn't thinking whatboutver specifically but the general trend that people have

very short terms employment in lower end jobs reachs rental wre you're right

right so

i think there's a reason for that i think it's because the site of socialization isn't at the workplace

that's my view

appreciated ined

man ar going whenever yeah ginji

is such an interesting guy gs you know he's

he's one of the few people that i can just talk to when he gets

it's a combination of being educated and not being arrogant

he's educated but he also doesn't bullshit around like a lot of academic

you know so hes he's perfect he's the perfect type of guy

throg a stream

i

a

oh

on sorry

looking at something

based convo appreciate

anyone can unionize at any moment why don't they sf their class conscerts

i think haes criticisms unions last am with sage

had married

i mean we have police unions

that's the

when i think too is

unions are

part of

the apparatus

of there's a lot this like an institution in america at least right unions

it's one

site

i

legacy institutions

where the union

can be swayed to the progressive side but it's not the union is in itself going to be the center

you know

but a union isn't like in the nineteenth century it's like all this is create a union

a union is a legacy institution

almost similar

to some type of like

hasn't

commune

i know it's going to mindfolk a lot of people that i'm comparing unions

peasant communes

but they are this kind of legacy thing

mostly when they wehre they matter you know

but maybe i'm talking on my ass i know what i'm talking about which is perfectly possible

p i'm willing to have someone come and come on

and explain to me

thank

the real

thing going on that i can't i'm not seeing and

i'm open to that so don't take me for dogmatism

i know groundworks but

those are places where people are concentrated

in one place

but i think that's just one piece of the puzzle

it misses the bigger pictre

were gl yeah

i've never seen a union

well i know my age group i know people who are my age

why do you think most people disregard dialectics

i mean i must seen chomsky say

you understand

it's mostly arrogance and it's not being able to understand limits

go on lefty pool you guys are to on lefty pool

for the last fifteen minutes or you want someone else

i think i'ming to end at nine

so this is going to be up to you guys

i

i think most people disregard dialectics because it's aul tomately a type of arrogance that's trying to foreclose themselves

to the radical

unknowability ultimate unknowability

of the other that also defines

we someone who rejects dialectics basically wants to control

every

right

if you accept dialectics you're at peace with the fact

there's always going to be

reality is always going to surprise you in ways you can't preemptively account

you know

it's always going to surprise you in ways you cannot preemptively

count

for the fact

and people who reject dialectics like chomsky are utterly humiliated by the

i

union seems to have no impact

interright can we review this song

it's called and cap grind

hoh

and cap grimd

okay

let's see

and cap grind

whatever that is

yeah i'm going to go on left youopant to say

one set

i think

what haveen was ste bests for combination of meeting people at one place yeah jennifer see jennifer thinks forward guys

jennifer thinks ahead she doesn't think dogmatically you know that's exactly my thoughts too

you kids just don't remember what you used to be in america's history

no chris you're right

you're right chris you're right

you're right but i'm just saying

almost similar to a peasant commune in the nineteenth century

i'm not sure we can just bring that back

but i agree that that's a really important part of the hisory

wait hoses back to his old habits going on lefty pool

now

i haven't gone yet and i'm not going to check our thread

i'm going to check a thread that

ginji sent us

sent me

about the laook con threat

but it's up to you guys it's seven percent at best today

en capsuleing

ho

i think we need something like that yeah i agree general

agree

i go you're saying i don't think unions will be essential that as in the twentieth century but i personally can't see ho we can do without them

like i said you know

yeah i'll check her out i'll see what's going on

unions are so intore just because the union somewhere

yeah i think

this new digital economy whatever

has completely changed

how people relate to

phenomena and how they distribute their attention

and unions

almost a s like

this is going to sound so crazy you going to take me out of context in to sound stupid

but it's almost like unions

weill have to compete with jake pauls

you do' guessing what i saying why that

like unions will have to make themselves sexy like fucking

riana some

like that's just the nature of how it is n'

not that infrared can compete with riano

can

at least we have some as that

kind of like stylist

thing

you and we try to draw attention with our thumbnails and music and o

units are like a concept socialsm and communism they can exist

any point

people choose

i don't think that's true for socialsm or communism either

and it i don't think that's true you know i think i think that's the issue chris

is that

the kids hearts and minds are distributed in ways that cannot

you can't just keep

telling them to

get with the program because

that itself is economic

like

if you want to tell the kids to form unions

that itself has to pass through the attention economy thresh

thresher

and you have to compete with jake pull

no

for attention

organizing on tick talk is actually popped off

answer a visionist comi of

what the fulk and tickt

we're not that deserate

year

introducing

comun i don't want to watch the j reg video dude

don't want to

i don't like j

all right let's check out this thing on lefty pool

this is going to be a chill lefty pole

thing

not a triggered one

don't worry we're going to going to

kindest piece of puzzle marks a stop

yeah i think there's a missing understanding of

subjectivity

in marxism in the west

loc cons definitely part of that

puzzle i agree with that

yeah but i don't think he meant the brain i think he just meant

subject to

and

do the autism box mem spread

spread

spread for fift five forty subs wow

oh what about the song what's the song called cap grind

what is it called the fhulosopher

like in yellow style bucky to the stadus it left a lot people but now you won't lfrad us thought you'd see the means gos of looking dangers

thel

w did not look great to hag your birthday gret

mashter

not sir

i'm not sure

ok i think it deserves more views though

you know

but

mm not sure much

ok y that's

some of it

cas a little bit

loc

cas a little bit

m

yeah

uh

sokl was right to critique lakan

what a fucking idiot

who's the duck

who's mentioning sokl i feel bad for whoever's mentioning sokl

that dumb ass soko was like

lakan said that the physical male organ is the same as the square root of minus one what nonsense

what a fucking arrogant dumbas

so calls the biggest bitch of all time fuck and dumb shit

stupid bok

adm me you're a dumb ass

and stop having an inferiority complex at being retarded

search left peole andanth them on you to by t's get out of left peole

this is not that long

h

s can understand this

everything set on infrared for me

kidd

but i actually understand all of this i understand all of this no joke i

no joke i

no joke i do the barred subject

little a objit petite

don't be intimidated by this shit its super easy to understand maybe i'll do a stream a bout it somem

search lefty pool anthem

okay

sure

if i cringe guys who do i blame

who gets to blame

who gets the blame if i cringe

what the fucg

which one do i click

oh this one

sanders you should loenti

so como

ok

yeah i know i know you understand it

you're one of the mightes and you tanky anthem i'

nh it's just let's go the red army song right

no it's not

y

right

ok

rog

do

thank

not too sure about that one gy's not too sure about that

not

not too sure about the

not too sure about that

that

not too sure about that

this is like the end of the road the most

the worst part of the fucking stream is one it browsing you

this

god damn it links tot work

i don't know why i can't every time i click on the link it doesn't work

used to enjoy that song hironically

that one or the red army one that the real one

a because the left pole one is a

i don't know

i kind of want this to happen do dot youuus kind of miss trump i kind of do

i kind of missed trump

n

guys remember remember when trump was president

yes remember trump was actually the u s president

and that was like

four years uy remember that

nosbll party of

i can't finish the the contre dude my i'm so tired

i'm worn out

too worn out

sorry

yeah i missed trump to

i'm to wn i let's see the nledgeable stuff

were already accused of bem nosbles

now it's going to be

thank

oh

ight

jesus right worreing

exiting out of that

eting e that one

little bit too far

little bit too far

ok

i

guys want to watch family guy

i

what is this

guys you know what i'm ft you want i tremble in fear

and sweat in fear

of the idea of

that when godzilla versus g comes out

in like two months

for one month i don't know what it's coming out

that king ong is going to lose to godzilla

and all of you guys in the chat are going to rub it in my face

you going to make means

of

someone

i of like voss defeating king kong and put my face on king kong

and i'm so it's like almost like i have skin in the game now

and i need godzill to i need king kong to win or i'll face

permanent humiliation

ginjed send me everything on twitter because on the chat it won't work

i actually fear that outcome

i don't know i just gave you guys that idea either i should have just

wa

you guys

yet

look at the twitter d m s you sent you didn't send any

oh you sent them five hours ago

videos unavailable

godzilla wins has has to quit infrared oh no

what's up justin wooton what's ub man you live in china

what's up man

what do you think about the aesthetic of vis on

cluster

okay

visy on

glass and hos

this is probably a leftist

this is russian hold on

me also get the other stuff

message

gn g

right

let's see what's going

china is definitely socialist yeah almost five years now

what up justin

will you

would you like to debate socialism dumb laug

i'll debate hm

why not

other btam i have like a battle plan to defeat empiricism

so itd be so easy

you know

us kept telling me about this guy right i checked out his channel and i watched almost all his videos so let's watch his d

this guy's kind of funny

let's watch this guy's bit

all right i'm going to watch all of these

b bit

what does this bef

you know you just got a class what's up real politics howre you doing

thoughts on radical empiricism

that's that american guy right what's his name

something something

how di you like him

how do we like that american guy

a got his nam

what is this beef

all right let me let me jump in on this beef and create some enemies ready even though i have any i don't care

i have nothing to do with this but to play the devil's advocate

play the devil's advocate

isn't this guy still in power

and

these guys aren't anymore

i don't know

just

not trying to take aside but

i don't know maybe i'm wrong

this is three minutes is too long

oh

hey do you

no where i can spam

i know do justin

america is totally different

totally different place even i got to be careful right now

because i can't

say

there's on the t v the will be watching mos board systm t

this guy was featured in black ops is not fucking crazy

that's fucking insane

that's crazy

crazy stuff

crazy

is in blackouts

six

sages are new like villain's a new punching bag of the show

is a new scaperoad

goofi stuff h

wow

m

if this is in russia

i can't speak down on it you know it's in russia my were

in america that might be kind of crzy

vot jessee i like just eventure a lot

you speak in german

who are these people

who are these people

crazy

sage not sage the guy sage but like the mem sage

how come leftists aren't like this in america

j wish american leftist were kind of like this

half of all easter

inside these guys

dud exactly do these are real

these are real leftist these are like real leftist you know

america w have fake leftis

these are actual real leftists

believe it or not

americans in the chat

guys

these are real lefs like this is the real thing and all the things you familiar with in america

completely fake

like this is actually real left

you know

dumbz

are you talking about

tagging achieves more than ten

i don't know dude i feel like these guys

other friends

i don't know their friends

i don't do they just have style and they have an attitude

and they carry themselves a certain way

that american leftists could not do american leftist

are masochistic

that is

masochism fetish pain fetish

and also moralizing and winding all the time

do these are real leftist because of how they carry themselves and i can tell the real leftists

these are they're about it they're not like these fake american leftists

we're always complaining about

bullshit

and whining all the fucking time

and leftism for them means like hey

don't step on that bug the bugs feelings shut up

yeah i know alexander exactly

toxic masculindy

so that's exactly what they would say here

it's exactly what left as you would say

the do like this is toxic masculinity

and it's making me feel really uncomfortable and the

they're also homophobicca it made that up to

the most mastream left we gt burg

i don't care about the suck them mean

but it's just the attitude of these people

you know it's like the attitude of the people in america

what do you think about a moral technique

bush knocked down the tower

that's

the're the guys who said bush knocked down the tower

' all i know about

dude in america these would be as accused of being fascists

i promise you this would be accused of being fascism in america

companies only works when the nationals on board with it

and njiust uss communism

i know i kind of know what you mean by national

yeah

attude

exactly

should we check the red one more time

and then call it a stream

is there anything new on the read it

let's do that

we're going to schacke the red it one more time

one more time

let me just see if there's any

i let's check the red it one last time they're going to call it

seen

gins eight hours

what up gins you

talki detected in gay

t one hundred

massad

m

okay

let's check what's coming

i saw hos from infrared at a grocery store in los and los angeles yesterday

i told him how cool it was to meet him in person

but it we to prison as i saying they said oh you're triggering me now

i was taking a back log ss ham but he kept cutting off and going ha ha

closing is su fri face a memembering insaw law

and i walked away continue my shopping and i heard him chuckle as i walked off

i saw hm to walk out the doors with a fifteen hideger books in his hands without pay

thehrot the cont very nice about a professional he was like ser you need to pay for those first and kept pretending i saw this mean before

right but let me just see what you're the

whatever the

i

scanning multiple times and you stop he and told you to scan them each individually

to prevent any electrical interference and then turn around and winked at me

and it's a word

she's scanned

true story by the way this actually is true

it actually did have

why did you

why did you come in for a stream as a white nationalist on your burner account

that wasn't me that was patricia

yeah

that's fucking incredible dude

strikes are here we go it's sage

howses and

dude they're all sage it's literally the feds sage is a fed

new mm sage is a fucking fed he's the i d f guy

he's the fucking filthy it's literally sage dude it's literally saye

it's literally say

dude this is a fulking fed

this is a fucking fed this is a balking fed i don't care i'm convinced now how can it be so many balking people doing the same tactics in the same balking shit this is a balcking

fd

in the fucking fed

thinks they know me psychologically

and think that i'm going to take debate and i'm going to

this fed wants me to goe lefty pool

and exhaust all my energy

writing

in corresponding with this fucking person because they want to stop infrared nice try fed nice try mossad nice try cia nice tried you glow we has baging to work

this streams going to keep on running a wasting no energy on that lefty bull thread so i can take the wae so i can take the energy and take it away from the sre streams going to keep on rolling you're not going to stop this you' not going to killus our great obit

we are going to buck and grow

nothing even do about it

bds you bought

lowi mos side beach i'm convinced this

literally a feed

literally afect

literally a fed he said go literally a fed

swear to god this is a fed i promise you i promise you this is a fed

thinking they're using psychological tactics

guys

i literally know what's going on

this is literally a fed

trying to use psychological manipulation

to waste my energy

from the stream

i swear

i'm almost certain of

maybe i'm wrong

they don't want

but this is really big glowy shit

tell me what guys it makes sense of this for me makes sense of this for me

sage calls himself a maoist

and who wants protracted people's war that's very glowy

because gloi's always want people to go

do dumbshit

by the way that w'll get him arrested

so that's a kind of glowy thing

then he's also a mossad guy

posting pro israel propaganda

o

k what does that have to do with my wisom how does that mix with my wisom

then

he's that

strikes or direct action mean to kind of aggravate me then he wants me to come on lefty pool and debate him

to

take the energy away from the stream and have me stream less often

so i can type

that's crazy twelve to thirty two it's crazy

connect those dots for me guys and then it's also filthy insurrectioni ist

who wants to get a rise out of me through the racism stuff

connect the dots guys

connect the dots

net

the dot

connect the fking dots

what is going on here

how do all those things connect guys

connect the fucking dots

i don't know if this is glowy shit

but it kind of seems like

loway

i don't know do

i don't know it seems like glowing

what is your favorite hob

be

infrared stream

but little did you know this is also sages the facade these are all this these are literally all the same people

this is all the same person

these are all the same people

this is literally all the same people

sage too is

this is age three

dude

next yeah exactly next thing i'm going to find out is that this is also neat

how many of you are saye

how many of you are safe

where does it end where does the fucking end am i crazy or what

whre is fucking and

where does this andend they're all saf

od

almost every single one is sa

i'm gonna i'm goinga open the stream one day and i'm goninga fukn see neat spam stri strikes a direct action

dude

i don't know i don't know i don'tus to say

mm

thud the mossad guy started saying strikes or direct action it's all fucking safe

that so

it's literally all see

i don't know what to say

ok

giving it introduction

but in verse

law use complex linguistic theory in german idealist philosophy

to introduction to newbies to dial like

n

bce

forgot to upfod this

as

i think that's it right

yeah that his

yeah guys join this let me see if other people joined

i think you're all joined

pretty much in this who are in the stream you've already joined

do join this base thats read it this read it so much fun

it's so much

our guys

it looks like

it looks like we've got to

yeah

yeah dude that's crazy it's almost kind of weird it's like

they're actually all the same person

literally all the same person

that is really sauce

really suce not going to lie you guys

super sauce

to prepare

i agree

i agree

i definitely agree alexander i am going to prepare better

sorry about that guys

definitely going to be more preparation

for the next one

i'm going to make a poll for our next edgy stream

actually i want to make the poll right now just so you guys have the opportunity

to vote

actually it's going to be ok let's just

what should the topic of our next edg you stream be

i want to do the imperialism one

we're going to run this for two days three days

forty

three days

right for three days

m going to tweet this out

put this right here

so yes can see

i guys it's going to have to call it to night

but

this was an awesome stream i had a lot of fun actually i love the stream a lot

and see you guys later

this was a really nice